Active Users:774 Time:26/01/2026 09:09:51 PM
Is Luke still the hero? As loud as the fans may be, you don't get to these numbers with them alone. Legolas Send a noteboard - 31/12/2015 07:06:05 PM

View original postAt some point it was Luke instead of Han who crossed Rey's path in TFA. They ended up scraping this and started again because they realized very fast that if Luke tagged along, they wanted it to be about Luke and much the same way the audience would be most interested in what Luke was doing, not Rey and Finn. That's when they decided that Luke had fled and the McGuffin became about finding his whereabouts, not old Jedi temples.

Or maybe they just realized that if they brought in the big hero on the good side from the start, it was difficult to have sufficient growth for Rey and Finn - regardless of audience interest.
View original postAs I'm sure they're aware, they'd have the same problem if they bring back Luke at the center of the action in the next movie. In TFA they walked a fine line with Solo (it worked, though many reviewers still thought Ford stole the show from the young cast...), but knew they could risk it as by the end they killed him, he wouldn't return as a Hero of the Resistance, leaving that role to the new trio.

The next movie, in my view, will be less bound by the old fans' expectations than TFA - and people may be overestimating how much TFA was, to begin with. One way or another, Luke will have to mentor Rey and then get out of the way - killing him off in the finale is one option, albeit perhaps a bit unoriginal.

I don't think the makers/writers are nearly as nostalgic about the characters as the older generations of fans, and both the massive box office success of this movie and Disney's general focus will be pushing them towards the newer viewers - in whose view Han Solo wasn't all that important, nor will Luke be unless the plot requires him to be.

View original postThis makes me believe they intend to confine Luke to the role of mentor (maybe even a very reluctant one. I expect Luke to be fairly "broken", more so than Obi-Wan and Yoda) or "quest giver" (they might bring back this idea of having to investigate old Jedi sites.. maybe Rey doing so for Luke now), which will be much easier now after TFA and a first confrontation between Rey and the First Order than it would have been in TFA, with Rey barely discovered by Luke. We'll no doubt see more of him with Rey, but I'm not quite sure he'll agree to return to the Resistance and Leia.

Sort of agree, although if he is indeed 'broken', it's another case of what I said about Kylo Ren in my previous post - not easy to get an audience to buy in to all that backstory if you can't take the time to really show it. And somehow Star Wars doesn't seem like the series to go with extended flashbacks? Old Jedi sites or some other kind of ancient history seems likely - after all, the Force has just 'awakened' again. Which no doubt would be linked one way or another to Snoke and the power sources of the First Order. As I mentioned, I'm probably more familiar with KotOR than with any movies, so I can't help being reminded of the Revan plotline.
View original postI suspect we might have to wait for the third movie to see a reunion of Leia and Luke - at a time the new heroes have advanced a lot more in their respective arcs, but it's just a hunch.

Could go either way, depending on how important Luke remains. If they indeed limit his role, or indeed kill him off during the second movie, it can be earlier.
View original postThe dilemma is that unlike Ben and Yoda (at the time of the OT) Luke used to be the hero, and to the audience he still is. It will be delicate to give the audience enough of Luke but without having him steal the show in a way Yoda or Ben couldn't.

Yeah, I'm not so sure about that, as mentioned above. The emotional side of things, anyway - viewed from a simple plot perspective, you obviously still have the usual mentor problem of nearly every fantasy story. Even if Rey does seem to have remarkably little need for a mentor.

Reply to message
Star Wars : The Force Awakens review (spoiler free) - 17/12/2015 09:18:26 AM 2740 Views
Love your review! I'm seeing it tomorrow night at 9pm. Can't wait! *NM* - 18/12/2015 01:20:16 AM 1047 Views
Some (relatively spoiler free) thoughts - 18/12/2015 12:27:22 PM 1829 Views
I pretty much agree with most of that. - 18/12/2015 01:05:16 PM 1696 Views
Agreed, Driver did a great job..... - 19/12/2015 05:46:44 AM 1570 Views
Replies and spoilers - 18/12/2015 03:04:37 PM 1666 Views
Re: Replies and spoilers - 18/12/2015 04:35:49 PM 1493 Views
Re: Replies and spoilers - 18/12/2015 05:51:29 PM 1594 Views
Re: Replies and spoilers - 29/12/2015 04:44:36 AM 1561 Views
Re: Replies and spoilers - 29/12/2015 07:37:39 PM 1511 Views
Re: Replies and spoilers - 19/12/2015 05:30:13 PM 1650 Views
Re: Replies and spoilers - 20/12/2015 09:51:22 AM 1749 Views
Re: Replies and spoilers - 21/12/2015 06:31:54 PM 1898 Views
The books... - 21/12/2015 09:05:28 PM 1675 Views
Re: The books... - 22/12/2015 03:12:52 AM 1653 Views
In general agreement ** potential Spoilers ** - 19/12/2015 06:06:23 AM 1544 Views
There are books? - 19/12/2015 11:19:07 AM 1588 Views
Re: There are books? - 19/12/2015 05:41:45 PM 1621 Views
So Darth Plagieus might still be in? Sweet. - 20/12/2015 04:44:21 AM 1511 Views
Palpatine's master? - 20/12/2015 02:25:45 PM 1593 Views
I mean the novel of that name. - 22/12/2015 09:47:16 PM 1541 Views
Re: I mean the novel of that name. - 22/12/2015 10:05:49 PM 1625 Views
Yeah, I think we're talking about the same one. - 24/12/2015 12:05:57 AM 1510 Views
Journey to Star Wars: The Force Awakens - 19/12/2015 06:07:16 PM 1623 Views
I don't think any of that had to be explained. - 19/12/2015 12:16:07 PM 1495 Views
I'm more or less in complete agreement (spoilers) - 19/12/2015 08:22:21 PM 1636 Views
Some thoughts about the Force... - 20/12/2015 06:04:43 AM 1697 Views
Re: Some thoughts about the Force... - 20/12/2015 08:06:40 PM 1484 Views
Re: I'm more or less in complete agreement (spoilers) - 20/12/2015 10:07:36 AM 1640 Views
Also, SPOILER thoughts. - 18/12/2015 01:00:32 PM 1806 Views
Re: Also, SPOILER thoughts. - 18/12/2015 01:11:30 PM 1602 Views
You're making me reply to two posts - 18/12/2015 03:29:23 PM 1679 Views
The death (spoilers) - 22/12/2015 10:30:05 PM 1608 Views
Re: You're making me reply to two posts - 29/12/2015 05:24:39 AM 1605 Views
Re: Also, SPOILER thoughts. - 29/12/2015 05:19:54 AM 1603 Views
I have tickets for tonight - 18/12/2015 04:47:17 PM 1559 Views
Arbrams impressed me(spoiler free) - 19/12/2015 05:17:42 AM 1699 Views
'Revenge of the Sith' (3rd prequel) was actually a decent movie - 18/12/2015 10:46:52 PM 1598 Views
They were all good. Internet geeks suck. - 18/12/2015 11:38:36 PM 1556 Views
Re: They were all good. Internet geeks suck. - 19/12/2015 12:19:10 AM 1741 Views
Well - 19/12/2015 05:53:56 AM 1563 Views
Re: They were all good. Internet geeks suck. - 19/12/2015 07:46:06 AM 1741 Views
people forget they were kids movies *NM* - 19/12/2015 01:17:10 AM 952 Views
Yeah, people take the whole 'Star Wars' thing too seriously - 19/12/2015 02:59:29 AM 1600 Views
BTW, Daniel Craig is totally forgiven for Spectre. He was a Stormtrooper (spoilers for role) - 18/12/2015 11:40:44 PM 1491 Views
Yip that's true *NM* - 19/12/2015 07:46:59 AM 989 Views
And Simon Pegg was the alien who ran the trading post Rey always went to *NM* - 20/12/2015 02:30:59 PM 1025 Views
I got the impression he was actually her boss or contractor - 28/12/2015 12:48:48 PM 1671 Views
Pretty much... - 29/12/2015 12:08:58 AM 1591 Views
Absolutely, yes *NM* - 29/12/2015 01:54:52 PM 1058 Views
Just saw it! Holy shit, shit, shit, shit.....it was amazing. - 19/12/2015 05:38:44 AM 1632 Views
Loved it (Spoilers) - 19/12/2015 06:16:54 AM 1604 Views
Fantastic characters, great entertainment, no originality, no logic - 29/12/2015 03:33:43 AM 1635 Views
Your Mom has no originality or logic! *NM* - 29/12/2015 11:39:41 AM 1007 Views
JJ Abrams should be able to do better than my Mom - 30/12/2015 04:20:54 AM 1574 Views
I gave it a B+ overall but I think the characters are its weak spot - 29/12/2015 05:08:15 PM 1400 Views
JJ Abrams' movies are character-driven, Lucas' movies are plot-driven - 30/12/2015 04:38:49 AM 1494 Views
Lucas has created some of the most iconics chacters in movie history ? - 31/12/2015 02:29:02 PM 1506 Views
So, Rey (Possible Spoilers ahead) - 30/12/2015 10:11:01 AM 1573 Views
Re: So, Rey (Possible Spoilers ahead) - 30/12/2015 07:10:56 PM 1896 Views
Re: So, Rey (Possible Spoilers ahead) - 30/12/2015 09:24:08 PM 1526 Views
Re: So, Rey (Possible Spoilers ahead) - 31/12/2015 04:58:24 PM 1472 Views
It was fun, and I look forward to the next ones, but can't say I was that wowed. - 30/12/2015 09:26:10 PM 1567 Views
Re: It was fun, and I look forward to the next ones, but can't say I was that wowed. - 31/12/2015 05:37:17 PM 1483 Views
Is Luke still the hero? As loud as the fans may be, you don't get to these numbers with them alone. - 31/12/2015 07:06:05 PM 1524 Views
Why is time for female lead and why does the lef think subtraction is the answer to inequality? - 04/01/2016 01:37:37 PM 1349 Views
Because the six other movies had zero female Jedis of any importance? - 04/01/2016 05:58:25 PM 1580 Views
Just another check the box movie, then - 04/01/2016 06:02:41 PM 1430 Views
Oh, come on. You're really going to complain just because they had a woman and a black guy? - 04/01/2016 11:48:52 PM 1558 Views
They are talking abou tmakin ght Gunslinger black - 05/01/2016 02:05:36 PM 1465 Views
Yeah, Star Wars is just part of the larger trend. It can't be viewed in a vacuum (pun intended). - 05/01/2016 02:38:34 PM 1445 Views
That's not really what I said, you'll note. - 05/01/2016 07:48:08 PM 1635 Views
I don't think it was Disney's business acumen. - 06/01/2016 06:59:46 PM 1693 Views
Wow. That's... sad. - 06/01/2016 09:32:37 PM 1628 Views
Re: Wow. That's... sad. - 08/01/2016 03:08:58 AM 1581 Views
I am noit sure how well that 7-12 girl demographic will work in merchandising - 08/01/2016 06:30:47 PM 1579 Views
Your premise is entirely wrong. - 12/01/2016 05:53:26 AM 1461 Views
Actually, they do have a major character who is Latino. - 12/01/2016 07:15:31 PM 1559 Views
The culture wars are just about blacks and feminists. - 13/01/2016 02:31:20 AM 1540 Views
All that Paul said - 17/01/2016 05:13:59 PM 2213 Views
LOL - 05/01/2016 06:33:50 PM 1461 Views
Funny that people use strwmen arguments to make themsleves feel smart - 08/01/2016 04:22:22 PM 1578 Views
It's not a straw man - 08/01/2016 04:52:03 PM 1544 Views
it was story of a father and son so it makes sense to male leads - 04/01/2016 06:59:33 PM 1399 Views
Male leads, sure, but it wasn't just the leads. - 04/01/2016 11:28:12 PM 1534 Views
Was finn as strong as Leia? I would say not even close - 05/01/2016 05:55:51 PM 1501 Views
I don't see how it makes sense to compare their roles, but Finn is certainly plenty strong. - 05/01/2016 07:38:05 PM 1576 Views
Finn reacts and is pretty much drug through the story - 06/01/2016 02:52:58 PM 1617 Views
Re: Finn reacts and is pretty much drug through the story - 06/01/2016 05:50:08 PM 1545 Views
I don't have an issue with a strong female jedi - 07/01/2016 02:49:44 PM 1516 Views
Re: I don't have an issue with a strong female jedi - 07/01/2016 03:26:34 PM 1541 Views
The reall issue it looks like Luke sucked as Jedi master - 07/01/2016 07:14:31 PM 1491 Views
Sorry, no. - 06/01/2016 06:56:09 PM 1586 Views
What a load of crap. - 08/01/2016 10:29:35 AM 1471 Views
I only partially agree - 08/01/2016 03:27:10 PM 1604 Views
Sorry if science isn't your thing but no what I said is true - 09/01/2016 11:49:15 PM 1626 Views
Re: Was finn as strong as Leia? I would say not even close - 08/01/2016 10:01:16 AM 1439 Views
Well said *NM* - 05/01/2016 12:01:25 PM 994 Views
Because it isn't "subtraction"... - 08/01/2016 09:33:24 AM 1498 Views
Of course it is - 09/01/2016 10:19:53 PM 1455 Views
Okay so about the big bad guy *spoilers* - 05/01/2016 06:27:37 PM 1530 Views
I may be alone on this, but... - 05/01/2016 08:07:26 PM 1528 Views
Re: I may be alone on this, but... - 05/01/2016 08:42:42 PM 1467 Views
What speaks against is for me... - 05/01/2016 10:57:44 PM 1887 Views
Re: What speaks against is for me... - 06/01/2016 10:08:35 AM 1673 Views
It's all good stuff, like the first book in a good sci-fi/fantasy trilogy! - 07/01/2016 06:44:45 AM 1567 Views
I think it's pretty obvious... - 17/01/2016 07:43:19 AM 1657 Views

Reply to Message