Active Users:617 Time:26/12/2024 07:55:36 PM
You should watch the first three seasons before commenting on these characters. Cannoli Send a noteboard - 24/04/2014 12:58:18 AM

View original post
Overall a bit of a filler episode that is still setting up future events quite nicely.
A few thoughts and questions:

Siblings Jaime and Cersei doing it in the septa next to their dead kid. That's pretty messed up. I am not sure that actually happened in the book and it didn't really fit with TV-Jaime's established character.


It's the "sept". Septa is a nun. So doing it in the nun is a whole other kind of perversion. As others have pointed out, it did happen in the book, and as for out of character, let's look at the other time the show portrays Jaime and Cersei having sex... oh, wait. We can't, because that was the scene that ended with his casual attempt at murdering a child. Among other murders alluded to and shown on the TV show, including that of a man established as a prior comrade in arms, just because he was pissed at the man's boss's wife.
Was Dontos killed in the book? I can't remember, but I don't think so. I don't think they should have done that, making Littlefinger the bad guy. He's not that black and white for me.
Holding a knife to Ned's throat with glee, while his hiring slaughters all Ned's men? Heavily implied threats to Ros to get her to stop mourning a murdered baby (which only happened because Littlefinger helped put the killer in power) and get back to being sexually objectified? Actually having Joffrey torture Ros to death because she wasn't happy about serving a guy like that? Explicitly evil actions aside, did you miss his rant back during the sexposition scene where he's training the hookers to be fake lesbians, all about how he has been plotting revenge against Ned & Catelyn for years? Or how Ros warned Shae to keep Sansa away from him?
Awesome final scene with Dany and her champion (much better than the first actor), the catapults and shackles. Too bad as a reader you already know she'll soon basically do nothing for an entire book and then loses everything.
Too bad as a reader, you should know that Littlefinger is pretty much the arch villain of the series, and evil mastermind of just about all the bad stuff that has happened, as well as probably being the guy who convinced Joffrey to kill Ned.
Opposed to the sentiments some people had in our discussion last week as to the details of the wedding, added scenes and skipped ones, I feel you can already tell there'll be a time when the show will be much better than the books. Not as detailed and rich, no. But so much more to the point and losing a lot of dead weight

You are seriously comparing the show FAVORABLY to the books in terms of dead weight? Which one introduced a completely gratuitous prostitute character, apparently solely for the purpose of titilation, and using up time that could be developing the consequential characters, only to kill her off without serving much purpose, other than possibly to illustrate Littlefinger's creepiness and evil. Said purpose apparently having been futile, as those characteristics have gone unnoticed. We get all kinds of dead weight like Lannister soldiers making crude jokes, in lieu of the actual battle of Oxcross. Rather than Oberyn's sexuality being casually referenced in a conversation, we have to have two more brothel scenes. The character in the books was a dangerous and unpredictable warrior, whose sexuality was merely the subject of rumors, which mostly served to illustrate who he considered himself unbound by cumstom or law. The guy on the TV show is a degenerate who lolls around in brothels with multiple prostitutes in two of the three episodes in which he has appeared, bullies lower-ranking men for being Lannisters, and is about as intimidating as Littlefinger. What could they have done with the money they wasted on sexpositioning the nature of his and Ellaria's relationship, which is really not that important to their characters? Emphasizing all the hookers they shared doesn't really add weight to her position as the voice of sanity when his daughters are spoiling for a fight over his non-murder.
we had to read through in FFC and DWD. So many characters are already approaching those points and they will have to come up with things to do while moving on. I am very excited to see the first parts of DWD on the TV screen.

If you are the type of person who needs to see movement to accept that something is happening, I guess the show is better fit for you. IMO, the stuff in Meereen was the most important, significant and interesting part of her entire arc, and did so much more to advance her character than a lot of wandering around letting people do things for her and tell her stories, in between bouts of indulging adolescent impulses, and getting away with it because dragons. In contrast to all the realistic interactions of characters and power or influence going on in Westeros, Daenerys story was a rather simplistic "return of the queen" type of story. Meereen is where she (maybe) learned that some problems can't be solved by mass murder, and the readers are signalled that her arrival on the shores of the Seven Kingdoms is not going to segue gracefully into "...happily ever after." It's where Martin gets realistic with the example of what is most likely to happen when you give even a well-meaning adolescent too much power (Robb being something of an abberration, who failed for lack of power, not a lack of maturity or restraint, and because Martin needed the traditional leader-types of House Stark out of the picture so the rest of the kids could rise from the ashes of absolute defeat).

Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Game of Thrones - Season 4, Episode 3 - 21/04/2014 02:46:59 PM 810 Views
Re: Game of Thrones - Season 4, Episode 3 - 21/04/2014 03:22:23 PM 811 Views
From what I know..... - 21/04/2014 03:29:30 PM 723 Views
Dontos - 21/04/2014 05:30:10 PM 595 Views
Huh, funny how the memory works sometimes. - 22/04/2014 12:08:03 PM 537 Views
Comments/Answers - 21/04/2014 06:19:22 PM 706 Views
You should watch the first three seasons before commenting on these characters. - 24/04/2014 12:58:18 AM 599 Views
I'll simply ignore the snark and reply to the points you actually made - 24/04/2014 09:10:15 AM 511 Views
Oh crap, an adult! - 25/04/2014 06:30:23 AM 592 Views

Reply to Message