Active Users:1007 Time:13/11/2024 06:38:08 AM
Oh, but Rigg really did it Cannoli .. DomA Send a noteboard - 15/04/2014 03:48:21 PM

She just did it so fast, like a cheap magician, that it's barely noticeable in real time (just the smallest hesitation in the movement of her arm going down, as she twisted and teared the stone away), but you clearly see her snatching the stone/vial if you freeze the right frame (linked picture with the stone in Olenna's fingers).

The necklace with a missing stone is clearly visible on the next shot of Sansa (no, it's not hidden behind her hair, it's really gone). Olenna took off the last stone on Sansa's left side.

http://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/s--0tsTwAPq--/c_fit,fl_progressive,w_636/pyznszcs3rxc9gofzul8.png

(sorry, that picture isn't as obvious as some others I've seen where the frame had been scaled up and you clearly see the empty socket, but it's the best I could find with Google.)

For sure this wasn't supposed to be noticed by 99% of the non-readers audience. It's only when Sansa notices one stone is gone that more people are going to remember that Olenna's the only one who fussed with Sansa's hair and necklace. But the production didn't cheat, they really had Diana Rigg do it on screen.

As for when she slipped the poison in the goblet, we don't see it happen on screen, but notice Olenna's focus of attention through the scene. Her plan was most likely to put it in Mace's chalice for the toast which was supposed to happen after the "main entertainment" (diverting suspicions because Margaery would have been expected to also drink from that chalice after Joffrey, supposedly after Joffrey said a few words after drinking, still leaving little time for the poison to act, and to stop Margaery from drinking), but Joffrey was going off program and Olenna seized the better opportunity of putting it in the goblet Sansa and Tyrion had just handled in front of everybody. Sansa in particular has given Olenna a golden opportunity by fetching the goblet from under the table.

IMO, Olenna did the deed while all attention was on Joffrey's antics. When she diverts Joffrey's attention from Tyrion to the pie, Margaery took his cup and placed it on her far right corner of the couple's table, closest to Olenna's place (but still not on the same table - and a few feet away), and the two exchanged a look. Then Olenna rose to applaud the release of the doves, and it could be when she managed to pour the poison, unless she had passed the poison to Margarery, who actually did it (next week's preview suggests that maybe Marge didn't know of the plan to murder Joffrey but... we'll see in context if she really says what we think she's saying... I think she might have done the deed without knowing that the substance given her by Olanna was poison). In any case, Tyrion had to come fetch the cup all the way on the other side of the couple's table, and for sure between the time Margaery took it from Tyrion and the time Tyrion grabbed it from the table, it's been poisoned by either Margaery or Olenna.

Martin and the director pulled it off quite well, I think. Part of the changes were there to help fool the audience and give them a bit of a whodunnit for one week. Martin is flexible and adapted quite well to the different codes used by the TV show.

Misinterpreting their body language and exchanges of looks, part of the non-readers already convinced themselves that Sansa in a suicidal move used nightshade procured her by Tyrion earlier, poured it in the goblet, which Tyrion saw, and in which he poured wine - and that Ser Dontos saw her do it and came to rescue her. Not sure what convinced them Sansa would be capable of a move like that, or why she prepared for an opportunity she was so unlikely to get, but oh well.

A whole lot of the rest seem convinced that Cirsei or Tywin or both scheming together had it done, through the pie instead of the wine. They think either stand to gain the most from the murder, having Tommen in reserve to offer the Tyrells, which isn't illogical. Tywin would be able to accuse Jaime's Kingsguard of failure and would have his excuse to get Tommen to expel Jaime, and send him to the Rock. Cirsei could believe that Tommen is too young for her to leave King's Landing and this might get her rid of Jaime (non readers have bought her act that she no longer cares for him...) while others believe she made a deal with Tywin to get out of her wedding to Loras, by putting Tommen on the throne, work to send Jaime to the Rock and get rid of Tyrion all at once. Not how the books's Lannisters would have thought, and not consistent with the show's Cirsei who will not doubt be doubly horrified that her sweet Tommen will be given by Tywin to Margaery, but oh well... (I suspect Cirsei's revenge on the show could involve finding a way for Ser Loras to enter the Kingsguard).

Some do suspect Olenna or Mace, but following the same logic many of the characters would follow, they doubt it as they don't see the Tyrells' interest in losing so much money and political efforts invested in that alliance, on the off-chance Tywin will agree to substitute the wedding to Joffrey to one between Margaery and Tommen, who can't even get Margaery pregnant with a son for a few more years.. and thus constitutes a far less solid alliance for the Tyrells. And if they wanted Joffrey dead, a quite reasonable assumption they would have most likely waited until Margaery bore a son from Joffrey. That explains why the Tyrells knew they wouldn't be suspected too much, but the audience underestimate the political daring, skills, and the military and financial leverage on the Lannisters until the war is truly over and paid for that Olenna possesses, which pretty much guaranteed Tywin would offer Tommen to Margaery as the only way to save the alliance.


Olenna grabbing the jewel/vial from the necklace
This message last edited by DomA on 15/04/2014 at 04:13:32 PM
Reply to message
Game of Thrones - Season 4, Episode 2 - Purple Wedding!!!!! - 14/04/2014 04:39:16 AM 844 Views
Well that was disappointing *NM* - 14/04/2014 07:15:14 AM 227 Views
Two things..... - 14/04/2014 03:13:07 PM 537 Views
It didn't feel right. - 15/04/2014 04:05:01 AM 608 Views
Some good points. - 15/04/2014 07:40:20 AM 635 Views
I haven't seen the fourth season yet, but one thing... - 15/04/2014 06:37:51 PM 731 Views
Re: I haven't seen the fourth season yet, but one thing... - 15/04/2014 10:18:55 PM 579 Views
Re: I haven't seen the fourth season yet, but one thing... - 15/04/2014 11:27:26 PM 623 Views
Maybe it's me who's misremembering, then. - 16/04/2014 06:12:41 PM 526 Views
Re: Maybe it's me who's misremembering, then. - 17/04/2014 01:37:50 AM 551 Views
those are all just "it wasn't the same as the book" arguments - 15/04/2014 05:34:34 PM 493 Views
Quite... - 15/04/2014 09:54:56 PM 554 Views
I didn't say it was bad - 15/04/2014 11:55:58 PM 654 Views
Don't see it..... - 16/04/2014 03:15:54 AM 513 Views
The Dragons... - 16/04/2014 03:47:48 AM 557 Views
I didn't see the episode.... - 16/04/2014 11:53:26 PM 588 Views
The term Purple Wedding troubles me - 14/04/2014 04:26:14 PM 676 Views
I assume..... - 14/04/2014 04:34:10 PM 563 Views
(spoilers) In the book... - 14/04/2014 08:03:45 PM 555 Views
Question..... - 15/04/2014 02:36:42 AM 528 Views
SPOILERS - 15/04/2014 05:23:22 AM 537 Views
Re: I assume..... - 14/04/2014 08:25:58 PM 536 Views
Interesting info on Jack Gleeson..... - 14/04/2014 04:41:28 PM 665 Views
He shouldn't have stopped Sigur Ros from performing. - 14/04/2014 06:53:50 PM 585 Views
It was for the most part very good (book spoilers) - 14/04/2014 10:47:14 PM 533 Views
I have to ask..... - 15/04/2014 02:32:36 AM 580 Views
If you really want to know (bookwise, I mean)... - 15/04/2014 07:46:15 AM 597 Views
Oh, but Rigg really did it Cannoli .. - 15/04/2014 03:48:21 PM 691 Views
DAAAAAAAAAAMN! - 15/04/2014 11:48:59 PM 619 Views
Re: DAAAAAAAAAAMN! - 16/04/2014 03:19:25 AM 815 Views
Pretty cool.....I watched that scene about 10 times and never saw..... - 16/04/2014 03:19:52 AM 479 Views

Reply to Message