Active Users:730 Time:25/11/2024 03:32:22 AM
Re: Cloud Atlas & Life of Pi Nate Send a noteboard - 13/03/2014 05:53:52 PM

View original post
So I will see the ending on TV before I read it. I have no problem with that, even if I may have preferred it the other way. I have yet to read a book of which I've seen the film first (even though I keep telling myself to, like Cloud Atlas, Life of Pi etc.), so I wonder if I'll be this invested in picking them up once I know how it ends.

The Cloud Atlas movie, I would argue, is better in a lot of ways than the book. The book is very well written, and the language in the future Hawaii scenario is easier to understand when you read it instead of hear it, but the overall plot is much less naturally cohesive. It's easier to understand and connect with the visual clues in the movie, such as the connected actors and the interweaving of scenes (which the book doesn't do). In addition, the future South Korea story has a more sensible and satisfying conclusion in the movie, I thought. I read the book before seeing the movie.

But the Life of Pi book, for me, was miles better than the movie (again I read the book first). The movie actually disappointed me compared to the book.

Warder to starry_nite

Chapterfish — Nate's Writing Blog
http://chapterfish.wordpress.com
Reply to message
HBO confirms that GAME OF THRONES will end after seven seasons - 12/03/2014 03:30:50 PM 1081 Views
Very interesting..... - 12/03/2014 05:13:18 PM 668 Views
Re: Very interesting..... - 12/03/2014 06:00:37 PM 700 Views
Start a commune out in the isolated Canadian wilderness? - 12/03/2014 06:19:21 PM 629 Views
Bet you $100 GRRM doesn't finish the series *NM* - 12/03/2014 06:24:55 PM 348 Views
HA! HA!.....maybe you can go to the Lost island. - 13/03/2014 01:49:32 AM 641 Views
Honey, kids, you know I love you... But here's a restraining order - 16/03/2014 06:01:33 AM 626 Views
THANK R'HLLOR! - 13/03/2014 04:55:29 AM 623 Views
I would have said "take 8 or 9" but it'll have to do. - 13/03/2014 01:02:22 PM 627 Views
Re: Cloud Atlas & Life of Pi - 13/03/2014 05:53:52 PM 706 Views
It would get boring long before season 9, that's for sure. - 14/03/2014 01:45:03 PM 630 Views

Reply to Message