Qui-Gon is the protagonist if you absolutely need one (though I don't know why you do)
Cannoli Send a noteboard - 28/02/2012 10:59:23 PM
But, whatever. It's for kids, that's fine. I disagree, and I think the fact that Lucas had the reservations you mentioned about Empire speaks volumes, but whatever.
But if they're for kids, what's with all the political/economic stuff? It's not something they're interested in, and it's not handled in an interesting fashion.
What's with the stuff about the Emperor disolving the Senate? What's with the issues of boarding a consular ship on a diplomatic mission? A lot of what goes on in the OT is beyond the comprehension of kids, like Jabba the Hutt's raison d'etre. But if they're for kids, what's with all the political/economic stuff? It's not something they're interested in, and it's not handled in an interesting fashion.
And if those scenes are for the "adults," then that opens the film up to other criticisms. The main one being that it is entirely possible to write stories and characters that are enjoyed by both kids AND adults.
Like all six Star Wars movies!There are plenty of examples of books and movies that are enjoyed on one level by kids and another by adults. The original trilogy, from what I've heard (I'm 26, so wasn't around when it first came out), was one of them.
Finally, a lot of the suggestions from the Youtube video aren't about it being a "kid" movie, other than maybe the snide remarks about Jar Jar. Phantom Menace DID suffer from a lack of a main protagonist.
How so? Why can't it just be classified as an ensemble? And what's wrong with Qui-Gon in that role? He's the one the PoV mostly follows, from the initial shots boarding the ship, to the subsequent battles and invasion. In fact, I would say that he dominates tPM more than any single character in any single movie, except possibly Luke in SWaNH. He's also the guy who gets everything done, from rescuing the queen & advising her to flee the planet against her instincts, discovering Anakin, betting their mission on his ability, freeing him, fighting off Darth Maul, and bringing both Anakin & the emergence of the Sith to the attention of the Jedi Council. Yeah, he didn't have much to do with Amidala's political storyline, but then neither did Luke with Leia & the Rebellion, aside from wanting to join it, in much the same way a high school athlete hopes to make a pro team some day. After his death Obi-Wan's subsequent action are entirely an extension of Qui-Gon's story - he slays Qui-Gon's killer, with Qui-Gon's weapon, and steps into his shoes to defy the Council and undertake the teaching of Anakin, when he had previously been vocal in his opposition to both courses of action. Finally, a lot of the suggestions from the Youtube video aren't about it being a "kid" movie, other than maybe the snide remarks about Jar Jar. Phantom Menace DID suffer from a lack of a main protagonist.
The space battle at the end of the movie WAS kind of stupid ("Oops! I accidentally fired a missile down a hallway and blew up an entire ship!"
I think we're meant to see that as him being run by the Force, and as an expression of how powerful it is in him. Qui-Gon specifically attributes his pod-racing skill to his Force talents, and his shout "Now this is podracing" as he flies through the enemy ship suggests he is feeling the same way he does during a race, when he is subsumed in the Force. (For the record, people talk about Darth Maul as a potential villain not because he was so amazing, but because there aren't many alternatives. Dooku and Grievous don't stir the imagination nearly as much as Maul did)
An aristocratic ex-Jedi stealing the moral high ground as the leader of a group with a legitimate beef with the Republic? Dooku was Robert E Lee and the two of them combined to foreshadow Anakin's fall, what with the cyborg-thing, the arrogant idealist falling to the Dark Side, the Sith apprentice being turned on by Palpatine/Sidious in favor of a fresh new apprentice?
Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
What if Episode 1 was good?
28/02/2012 05:11:40 AM
- 1067 Views
Talking people are annoying, especially when their first idea is stupid
28/02/2012 01:51:50 PM
- 588 Views
Re: Talking people are annoying, especially when their first idea is stupid
28/02/2012 02:12:37 PM
- 709 Views
Are you talking about the guy with the deep thick voice who affects a stupid tone?
28/02/2012 06:29:15 PM
- 514 Views
Errrr you're not really addressing the video
28/02/2012 02:55:46 PM
- 694 Views
Re: Errrr you're not really addressing the video
28/02/2012 04:22:16 PM
- 732 Views
Because 7-10 year olds are really into trade regulation?
28/02/2012 07:42:43 PM
- 462 Views
Qui-Gon is the protagonist if you absolutely need one (though I don't know why you do)
28/02/2012 10:59:23 PM
- 509 Views
Actually, I didn't get that far. The guy annoyed me so much I shut it off after the last point
28/02/2012 06:45:43 PM
- 558 Views
Hah, I do!
28/02/2012 07:55:52 PM
- 450 Views
Re: Actually, I didn't get that far. The guy annoyed me so much I shut it off after the last point
15/03/2012 02:10:17 PM
- 510 Views
Re: Talking people are annoying, especially when their first idea is stupid
28/02/2012 03:16:48 PM
- 562 Views
I'd really like to see some discussion with Lucas being challenged
28/02/2012 08:05:16 PM
- 561 Views
There is little to none canon that doesn't get signed by Lucas and his little helpers
28/02/2012 10:30:34 PM
- 449 Views
Re: There is little to none canon that doesn't get signed by Lucas and his little helpers
29/02/2012 12:48:54 AM
- 495 Views
I mean, the Solo/Leia love story wasn't particularly complex
29/02/2012 06:42:37 PM
- 474 Views
Re: I mean, the Solo/Leia love story wasn't particularly complex
02/03/2012 06:06:48 PM
- 605 Views
I thought the Padme-Anakin relationship was kind of plausible, just not addressed well in the films
02/03/2012 08:52:52 PM
- 496 Views
Who here thinks they could make a better Episode I ?
06/03/2012 06:43:58 PM
- 460 Views