Strange... This is the first episode that disappointed me
A Deathwatch Guard Send a noteboard - 30/05/2011 09:09:20 AM
Maybe it's because I've started rereading the series in preparation for the fifth book, and finally caught up and passed the show, so I had the book version of events fresh in my mind, but it seems to me that they deviated a lot more from the book here than in previous episodes.
Furthermore, there are the entirely unnecessary scenes that aren't in the book at all. Seeing Tywin was great, and I think the actor did an excellent portrayal of him, but why was that scene there, exactly? It isn't in the book, and it doesn't even make sense given the book's chronology of events. And Littlefinger's scene with the whores was little more than a waste of five minutes to include more boobs in the episode.
It was still fairly good overall, but I feel like they padded the episode with too much unnecessary junk, just to stretch it out and make it end on a climactic note, which is probably going to be a major problem with the pacing of the episodes. The chapters of the books do not have weekly interludes, they continuously hammer the reader, and then they hammer the reader even further, while the show does not seem willing to live up to that.
Furthermore, there are the entirely unnecessary scenes that aren't in the book at all. Seeing Tywin was great, and I think the actor did an excellent portrayal of him, but why was that scene there, exactly? It isn't in the book, and it doesn't even make sense given the book's chronology of events. And Littlefinger's scene with the whores was little more than a waste of five minutes to include more boobs in the episode.
It was still fairly good overall, but I feel like they padded the episode with too much unnecessary junk, just to stretch it out and make it end on a climactic note, which is probably going to be a major problem with the pacing of the episodes. The chapters of the books do not have weekly interludes, they continuously hammer the reader, and then they hammer the reader even further, while the show does not seem willing to live up to that.
GoT 1.07 "You Win or You Die" (Early viewers thread) SPOILERS
24/05/2011 01:49:47 AM
- 1736 Views
Re: GoT 1.07 "You Win or You Die" (Early viewers thread) SPOILERS
24/05/2011 03:32:57 AM
- 1081 Views
Yes, I kind of like Cersei as well.....
24/05/2011 04:51:38 AM
- 932 Views
Holy Crap was that ending perfect....."I did warn you not to trust me" -
24/05/2011 04:40:33 AM
- 941 Views

Strange... This is the first episode that disappointed me
30/05/2011 09:09:20 AM
- 881 Views
I see your point but disagree
30/05/2011 09:20:23 AM
- 839 Views
I agree, those scenes were very necessary.....
30/05/2011 05:01:06 PM
- 696 Views
Hmhm yes and no
30/05/2011 05:07:52 PM
- 803 Views
You know, GRRM likely was very supportive of the scene.....
30/05/2011 05:10:58 PM
- 743 Views
Maybe, but GRRM isn't God and I allow myself to have a differing opinion
*NM*
30/05/2011 05:13:14 PM
- 383 Views

Brothels are a way of life in this epic story and play an important role. *NM*
31/05/2011 02:32:25 AM
- 430 Views
No they don't.
31/05/2011 11:08:36 PM
- 783 Views
Apparently you haven't read the books because they are all over in them. *NM*
31/05/2011 11:45:58 PM
- 358 Views
Afer reading your profile, you did read the books, but missed all the brothels in them. *NM*
31/05/2011 11:47:51 PM
- 396 Views
I recall the brothels
01/06/2011 12:56:32 AM
- 908 Views
The stuff Littlefinger said was really important and needed to be in there.
04/06/2011 07:13:41 PM
- 791 Views
Agreed! Another awesome epside!
30/05/2011 10:04:59 PM
- 1019 Views
One other thing to think/worry about.....
30/05/2011 11:04:47 PM
- 834 Views
You can't stay away from spoilers, can you?
30/05/2011 11:59:39 PM
- 790 Views

Re: You can't stay away from spoilers, can you?
31/05/2011 05:49:33 AM
- 717 Views

There will be lots of white-walker stuff in season 3 (spoilers in case you don't get it)
31/05/2011 08:54:13 AM
- 943 Views
You make an interesting point *future spoilers*
31/05/2011 10:47:29 AM
- 892 Views
Re: You make an interesting point *future spoilers*
31/05/2011 01:21:06 PM
- 794 Views
The problem I have with it is the heavy handedness of some scenes
31/05/2011 12:14:13 PM
- 795 Views
Agreed, and this is probably the cause, at least in part, of a lot of my complaints above
31/05/2011 07:17:34 PM
- 745 Views
Re: Agreed, and this is probably the cause, at least in part, of a lot of my complaints above
31/05/2011 08:58:44 PM
- 701 Views
What did Littlefinger do in the book.....how did the final scene of the episode go down?
31/05/2011 09:19:18 PM
- 726 Views
Re: What did Littlefinger do in the book.....how did the final scene of the episode go down?
31/05/2011 11:13:35 PM
- 762 Views
I assume at some point they are going to tie the two story lines together?
01/06/2011 02:43:12 PM
- 662 Views