Key:
Met Muad before
Borderlander
Noble
Players
Amys: Is a banker from unknown nationality who speaks in riddles and codes. She doesn't seem to trust Muad, if I understand correctly.
Overall, I'm not sure what to make of Amys, but I can't say I trust her.
: A guard-for-hire from Lugard. Currently RSIRL.
Don't know why, but my gut says he's probably Light.
Bergioyn: One of three who've claimed to be Saldaean. I wonder if the Saldaeans know each other? Especially the nobles. He also came up with the idea that the amulet could change the alignment of the bearer.
Not entirely sure why, but I get a DF feel from him. Seems like maybe he might know too much about the amulet, and I'm not sure what to make of the multiple Saldaean claims.
beetnemesis: Taraboner historian. Incidentally, the only person to claim that he has a known purpose for being summoned to Muad's Manor. Did a bit of a flip-flop on the whole claiming nationalities thing.
He's on my suspect list, but there isn't exactly a smoking gun, per se.
BlackAdder: I'm a Cairhienin soldier. I'll let you figure out the rest
Darth Katie: From Tear. RBIRL.
That's all that's known about her. I'm going to reserve judgement...
Fanatic-Templar: From Arafel. His only comments have been about whether or not there will be multiple factions.
My mind thinks he's more likely to be a DF but gut says he's probably OK to trust, but really don't have much to go on.
fistofpainx: Illianer merchant. Hasn't really said anything.
Gonna reserve judgment again...
Fox and Ravens: One of the three Saldaeans, but did not claim to be noble. One of the 4 who've claimed to have met Muad before, too.
Frankly, I'd like to hear more from both of the Saldaean and "we've met Muad before" groups. He fits into both. E.g., how did they meet Muad before? Do the Saldaeans know each other?
Gher: From Ebou Dar (Altara). He thinks amulet is not a SL relic.
Really I have no judgement either way on Gher.
Hieshyn: ?
Darkfriend
Hobo: A fellow Aiel war veteran, who doesn't know his nationality. He didn't respond to my speculation that he was aan'allein.
Hmm, overall I get a bad feeling from him.
Kronin al'Sulc: Malkieri/Shienaran. One of two to claim Shienar (w/ ranagrande). RBIRL.
Reserving judgement...
Napoleon62: An Andorman who first suspected beetnemesis for being the only one with a reason for being summoned.
I have a good feeling he is for the Light.
ranagrande: One of two to claim Shienar (w/ Kronin al'Sulc).
I wonder if the Shienarans know each other?
Talic: A Tinker. He was skeptical that the amulet would do anything.
Gut thinks he's a DF, but I don't know why.
White Flame of Tar Valon: From Kandor. Didn't notice that people had claimed the same nations more than once.
Generally, I have a feeling he is for the Light, though.
Yunalesca: One of three who claimed to be Saldaean (w/ Bergioyn and Fox and Ravens). Is also noble (w/ Bergioyn). She commented that she would rule out that the amulet is just a SL relic.
Again, she is on my list for more interrogation due to being a member of the Saldaean trifecta.

So, as a summary, I think if we had to lynch someone, I would be most comfortable with that being Hieshyn. But looking over the rules, it seems that an inactive player will get a warning, then get modkilled anyway. If I'm reading correctly, a week of continuous inactivity (without any RBIRL posting) would be enough to get a player modkilled. So, I'd say we hold off on lynching him, and maybe he'll just get modkilled and we can lynch someone else. That way, we would get an extra lynch, which is great for the Light.

In addition, I think we should take a closer look at the three Saldaeans (Bergioyn, Fox and Ravens, Yunalesca), the two Shienarans (Kronin al'Sulc and ranagrande), and the four who've met Muad before (Amys, Artsapat, Fanatic-Templar, Fox and Ravens). Fox and Ravens is in two of these groups.

I would like to know: Do the Saldaeans know each other, and how? Same for the Shienarans. Is there some kind of Borderlander affilation?
And, for Muad's acquaintances, how do they each know him?