Let's follow the logic here:

1) You throw out various random theories about game format which have no evidence backing them, all of which are actually counter-indicated by the very thing you pointed out, the Mod's desire for a game of 12.

2) You claim that these are totally random general brainstorms base don nothing but educated guesswork.

3) I say I find that improbable, and that your picks, which again are counter-indicated by the specific game size requirement, seem way more likely to be water-testing or a series of randoms wrapping around something you want to have us believe, be it true or fabricated.

4) You claim I am suspicious for saying I don't believe they're totally random general brainstorms, because you didn't attempt to explain your logic or explain why mine was wrong, and you're claiming no special knowledge or else accusing me of accusing you of special knowledge would be pretty weird.

Pause: You are specifically claiming, by that statement, that the various talk of multiple Scum Factions or multiple individual SKs really was just random brainstorming.

5) You say, "you're scum, either part of a team or one of our serial killers."

I don't believe we've ever had multiple SKs in one game before, certainly it would be very rare, so you seem surprisingly sure of that, to bring it up again, especially since - again - a fixed number of players doe snot indicate multiple NK factions in anyway at all.

Ditto it would be really weird to jump from me doubting the validity of your theories or purity of your motives to "Isaac is, automatically, a scummer." That's just not logical, and it's basically an OMGUS act, and it implies you do have knowledge too, but since the nature of your counter accusation is to say you don't, that's not a very townie stance to take.