Isaac had some deep thoughts on your post, I'm just a simple guy To me there's not much of an analysis but only a bunch of (educated) guesses. I agree the specific wish to get 12 players stands out, but for now we have no clue what that means. You point out that there are multiple variations, varying from 2 groups (town-scum) to 3 of 4 players or 4 of 3 players. Well...I wonder if there were any players who hadn't thought of that before. Not very new, at least to me. BUT...I lured you out of your comfortable cosy chair and got you posting ^^