... but my Vote is not based solely on the number of posts. We're semi-randomly looking for the least Pro-Town player, as we have to assume that even the Scum will act either Pro-Town(-ish), or will try to hide between the discussion by others. In that respect, both deserve a FoS.
The reason for going to FT's side is that he seems to be participating (as in: he posts), but it seems to be that he's hiding in the discussion by primarily participating in non-game related posts. At a cursory glance, this looks like doing his job, without actually accomplishing anything.
Granted, the accusation is slim, maybe not even worth a FoS in normal circumstances, but since Day 1 is probably based on slim accusations anyway (and a OMGUS here and there - I'm looking at you Dannymac now) we might as well go with what we have.