It kinda seems like Hieshyn and ? are our logical lynch targets, plus Cop (Table) - Edit 1
Before modification by Isaac at 11/11/2011 11:30:21 PM
We don't really know the score, but 6 cops of varying degrees of sanity seem like safe bets as "Are town, to the best of their knowledge" and if we do have a scum faction they'd seem like the obvious suspects as vanilla claims, which would be the probable Day 1 fake RC, presumably starting with ?. Hopefully the level of Mind Screw is limited to the cop weirdness and we can lynch them and today and tomorrow and chalk up a win. Either way, lynching one of them today seems pretty much a given, now that everyone has decoded and had that decode confirmed as valid. We should consider copping strategies, so let me reprint our results thus far:
Non-Applicable
Darth Katie - Dead without role or chance to extract it, but was town and was probably a cop variant
? [original] - Day Cop, never had a chance to investigate
? [current] - vanilla claim
Hieshyn - vanilla Claim
Normal Cop
Isaac ---> Beetnemesis, Guilty
Ranagrande ---> ?v2, Guilty
Stephen ---> Ranagrande, Innocent
Yunalesca ---> ?v1, Innocent
Day Cop
Beetnemesis ---> Isaac, Innocent
Fox and Ravens ---> ?, Innocent
?v1 ----> Dead before investigation
So 4 cops, 3 Day Cops, 2 vanilla and one unknowable. I'd guess DK was a Day Cop and we were 4 and 4, though we might have had 3 day cops strictly to ensure in game design that no possible Lynch/NK combination could keep the town from having at least one Day Cop come Day 2, so DK could have been a normal cop, a vanilla, or some role. I'd also point out that IIRC FT subscribes to miller's being unaware, so psycho cop isn't our only option, that role is totally stackable with other roles. At the moment though, assuming the various cops are town and that the vanillas are scum, I would appear to be the only person who got an untrue result, if ?'s is town though then both Rana and I would have untrue. Personally I'm giving serious thought to self-investigating tonight, though that will depend on the reveal off our lynch, which I think will probably be ?, the scum (or whatever) might lop off my head though that seems only semi-likely since they can kill whoever they feel like and I'm probably insane. If ? dies scum, we should probably all either investigate Hieshyn, ourselves, or aim for a kind of random distribution... if he dies town, then Stephen and Yuna, who will be the only options for sane cops as Rana and I will preusmably both have been wrong, should probably hit Hieshyn, one of them will survive at least, and me and Rana should either self-investigate or pick other cops to check.
Non-Applicable
Darth Katie - Dead without role or chance to extract it, but was town and was probably a cop variant
? [original] - Day Cop, never had a chance to investigate
? [current] - vanilla claim
Hieshyn - vanilla Claim
Normal Cop
Isaac ---> Beetnemesis, Guilty
Ranagrande ---> ?v2, Guilty
Stephen ---> Ranagrande, Innocent
Yunalesca ---> ?v1, Innocent
Day Cop
Beetnemesis ---> Isaac, Innocent
Fox and Ravens ---> ?, Innocent
?v1 ----> Dead before investigation
So 4 cops, 3 Day Cops, 2 vanilla and one unknowable. I'd guess DK was a Day Cop and we were 4 and 4, though we might have had 3 day cops strictly to ensure in game design that no possible Lynch/NK combination could keep the town from having at least one Day Cop come Day 2, so DK could have been a normal cop, a vanilla, or some role. I'd also point out that IIRC FT subscribes to miller's being unaware, so psycho cop isn't our only option, that role is totally stackable with other roles. At the moment though, assuming the various cops are town and that the vanillas are scum, I would appear to be the only person who got an untrue result, if ?'s is town though then both Rana and I would have untrue. Personally I'm giving serious thought to self-investigating tonight, though that will depend on the reveal off our lynch, which I think will probably be ?, the scum (or whatever) might lop off my head though that seems only semi-likely since they can kill whoever they feel like and I'm probably insane. If ? dies scum, we should probably all either investigate Hieshyn, ourselves, or aim for a kind of random distribution... if he dies town, then Stephen and Yuna, who will be the only options for sane cops as Rana and I will preusmably both have been wrong, should probably hit Hieshyn, one of them will survive at least, and me and Rana should either self-investigate or pick other cops to check.