Honestly, I wasn't trying to start a giant thing against Isaac. I collated the (very few) things that seemed like points of interest, and mentioned them. Isaac did a giant rebuttal, then I wanted to respond to a few points he'd made, and it became a whole big thing.

I'm not as sold as the rest of you on Isaac's innocence, but I'm fine with dropping it for now.


As for ?, I was just going to write it off as a simple mistake. He's apparently falsely claimed vanilla in the past when he was scum, though, so that is a red flag.

A minor note to point out, that it does seem likely he is Achilles- his Day One question responses basically confirm it. That doesn't mean he's not scum, but it does mean he's telling the truth about his character.

Would Achilles have any reason to be angry at the gods?