I'm entirely open to the idea that WF isn't a SK, but if anything, his Watcher claim set off alarm bells in my head because it was such a 'safe claim'. Why are you surprised no one has counter-claimed? I can't even remember us ever having a watcher role in play, if he'd claimed Tracker or something, yeah, I'd buy it, we've had those roughly half the games so no one wants to fake claim it, too risky, but Watcher? Just like Lie Detector, its so uncommon in the game series its safe, minimal risk of a counter-claim.