Re: I have to say I'm a little... disappointed
White Flame of Tar Valon Send a noteboard - 26/08/2010 06:43:44 AM
The town killed scum left and right, got lots of successful protects, and still ended up losing. We started with 18 players...
possible scum:
4 mafiaA
3 mafiaB/cult
1 miller/SK (better count this twice, since it's 2 lynches to get rid of the one)
That's 50% of the players as possible scum... way too much for the town imho.
Then lets look at the accuracy rate of killing scum..
We lynched 2 mafia and a serial killer vs. 3 townies (and 1 was Yuna asking to be lynched... don't count this one against us seriously - Kylia and I were totally against it the first time; most of the people voting her were *gasp* scum) - that's 50-60% success lynching scum which is pretty good for the town. In addition to that, we got 2 successful night kills in our favor with no losses. No night kill night 1. The town played this one about as well as it could.
In fact, the town played this too well. It got punished for actually lynching the mafiaA since really what the town needed to win was for the mafiaA to kill mafiaB (the town couldn't realistically hope to win by lynching or night killing EVERY bad guy - there were way too many). So when the town focused down on mafiaA... they lost.
If White Flame really was a cop/tracker role, then honestly that group is really overpowered. A cultist cop that basically confirms the other cult members is virtually unbeatable.
I think White Flame should have been lynched after Darth Katie, but honestly Yuna made a completely useless roleclaim and character claim (Dark One) that pretty much sealed the win for the cult/mafiaB, not for the first time in the game either lol (town got punished pretty badly for lynching her 3 times). Getting White Flame lynched wouldn't have been easy, but it probably could have been done, assuming Kylia would actually have voted for someone lol
yeah, I'm a little upset cuz town got the shaft here
possible scum:
4 mafiaA
3 mafiaB/cult
1 miller/SK (better count this twice, since it's 2 lynches to get rid of the one)
That's 50% of the players as possible scum... way too much for the town imho.
Then lets look at the accuracy rate of killing scum..
We lynched 2 mafia and a serial killer vs. 3 townies (and 1 was Yuna asking to be lynched... don't count this one against us seriously - Kylia and I were totally against it the first time; most of the people voting her were *gasp* scum) - that's 50-60% success lynching scum which is pretty good for the town. In addition to that, we got 2 successful night kills in our favor with no losses. No night kill night 1. The town played this one about as well as it could.
In fact, the town played this too well. It got punished for actually lynching the mafiaA since really what the town needed to win was for the mafiaA to kill mafiaB (the town couldn't realistically hope to win by lynching or night killing EVERY bad guy - there were way too many). So when the town focused down on mafiaA... they lost.
If White Flame really was a cop/tracker role, then honestly that group is really overpowered. A cultist cop that basically confirms the other cult members is virtually unbeatable.
I think White Flame should have been lynched after Darth Katie, but honestly Yuna made a completely useless roleclaim and character claim (Dark One) that pretty much sealed the win for the cult/mafiaB, not for the first time in the game either lol (town got punished pretty badly for lynching her 3 times). Getting White Flame lynched wouldn't have been easy, but it probably could have been done, assuming Kylia would actually have voted for someone lol
yeah, I'm a little upset cuz town got the shaft here

yea I was glad that you all decided the Dark One was a greater threat than a person with robotic implants. And if you really thought I should've been lynched next you shouldn't have bothered protecting me


RAFO Mafia 17: The End
26/08/2010 04:59:22 AM
- 756 Views
OH YEAH!
26/08/2010 05:18:19 AM
- 610 Views
Were you guys a cult? *NM*
26/08/2010 05:35:05 AM
- 369 Views
I have to say I'm a little... disappointed
26/08/2010 05:52:36 AM
- 643 Views
I suspect the Borg were a Cult
26/08/2010 06:02:00 AM
- 645 Views
Not even after they've gotten a proven guilty on someone?
26/08/2010 06:06:52 AM
- 706 Views
Keep in mind they tend to get axed
26/08/2010 06:13:34 AM
- 662 Views
That should have happened, but not the case here. *NM*
26/08/2010 06:15:26 AM
- 379 Views
See Fox's night 2 message
26/08/2010 06:37:57 AM
- 606 Views
Yeah, that's part of the reason I suspected you, in fact.
26/08/2010 06:16:31 AM
- 669 Views
Re: Yeah, that's part of the reason I suspected you, in fact.
26/08/2010 06:25:14 AM
- 701 Views
You know what's really weird?
26/08/2010 06:31:01 AM
- 691 Views
Re: You know what's really weird?
26/08/2010 06:43:28 AM
- 644 Views
For the record...
26/08/2010 06:48:40 AM
- 622 Views
Re: For the record...
26/08/2010 07:06:55 AM
- 644 Views
That's partly my fault.
26/08/2010 07:48:02 AM
- 751 Views
Re: That's partly my fault.
26/08/2010 09:05:14 AM
- 771 Views
Yeah, there were a lot of things that hurt the town in this game
26/08/2010 06:06:08 AM
- 570 Views
Incidentally, getting Shai'tan as a pro-town role is seriously rough luck.
26/08/2010 06:10:49 AM
- 769 Views
Actually he was a Miller
26/08/2010 06:14:07 AM
- 598 Views
Re: I have to say I'm a little... disappointed
26/08/2010 06:43:44 AM
- 678 Views
Role messages
26/08/2010 05:57:42 AM
- 1401 Views
Night 2 messages
26/08/2010 06:16:15 AM
- 652 Views
Night 3 messages
26/08/2010 06:29:47 AM
- 761 Views
Night 4 messages
26/08/2010 06:36:16 AM
- 870 Views
heh, beet/Kylia actually did end up confirming White Flame as a tracker.
26/08/2010 07:09:36 AM
- 662 Views
So ranagrande, it was just completely random which ghost she saw?
26/08/2010 07:15:39 AM
- 814 Views
That Barbie role is pretty cool
26/08/2010 07:03:19 AM
- 626 Views
I'm curious who else got asked night questions by Kylia
26/08/2010 06:29:44 AM
- 705 Views
Yay!
26/08/2010 06:39:24 AM
- 615 Views
woe, my roles were nasty
*NM*
26/08/2010 09:03:35 PM
- 323 Views

I think being lynched three times in one game is a record.
26/08/2010 09:19:36 PM
- 627 Views
And all three were similar in that she was basically asking to be lynched
27/08/2010 01:26:18 AM
- 641 Views