And with analysis - please feel free to explain why you think my qualifiers on MRE are wrong, there's room for interpretation but again, Captain Kirk and Rand Al'Thor are absolutely not form the modern world and have no business with a yes or even an UNC.

Amys
MRE: UNC
MCS: UNC
GEN: Male
No yet given

Artsapat
MRE: UNC
MCS: No
GEN: Male
Professional Wrestling
Monopoly, The Game
American Idol
GI Joe
The Apprentice

As UNC goes for MRE, GI Joe and Monopoly qualify, tough GI Joe barely, Apprentice, Pro Wrestling and Americna Idol are clearly "Yes"


beetnemesis
MRE: Yes
MCS: Yes
GEN: Male
Sluggy Freelance
Advertising Mascots
Christian Folklore
Jewish Folklore
James Bond

MRE of Yes absolutely doesn't get to include anything called 'Folklore', but would include Bond, James Bond, and many mascots in ads.

BlackAdder
MRE: No
MCS: No
GEN: Male
The Jungle Book
Aesop's Fables
The Chronicles of Narnia
Garfield
The Wind in the Willows


Well, Garfield is a Yes or maybe a thin UNC, otherwise consistent, and Garfield is ruled out by a MCS of 'No' since it has few characters and is pretty well known anyway.

Darth_Katie
MRE: UNC
MCS: No
GEN: Male
Looney Toons
Dexter's Lab
Barbie
The Simpsons
South Park


Simpsons and South Park are "Yes", so is Barbie, and I think Dexter too, Looney Toons, primarily dating to WWII era would get an UNC, especially with lots of off-world and time-travel/future stuff, but is definitely a Yes on MCS, it is Looney Toons, even an UNC would be questionable, though that may be my age bias, back in my day Looney Toons was still the major run kid's cartoon.

Fanatic-Templar
MRE: Yes
MCS: UNC
GEN: Male
None Yet Given

Can't do much with that

Fox and Ravens
MRE: UNC
MCS: UNC
GEN: Male
Star Trek
Sonic
A Song of Ice and Fire
Spaceballs
Willy Wonka-verse


Start Trek, Sonic, SotF and Spaceballs are so far from MRE-YEs that and UNC isn't even plausible. Will Wonka would be a legit UNC, that's it

Hobo
MRE: Yes - changed to No
MCS: Yes
GEN: Male
Shakespeare plays
Wheel of Time
Enders Series
Robin Hood
Greek Myths

I was baout to cry foul on Hobo since not a darn one of those fits, but IIRC he amended his result and I haven't. Obviously, none of these are modern/real earth, which fits his changed answer

Isaac
MRE: UNC
MCS: UNC
GEN: Male
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Indiana Jones
Marvel Comics
Whedonverse
Dark Shadows

I think I've previously explained how these were all UNC, but yes it matches up.

Kronin al'Sulc
MRE: UNC
MCS: UNC
GEN: Female
Dr. McNinja
Barbieverse
Clue
Pokemon
American Idol

One of our two admitted 'female' characters (other is Napoleon, and maybe Blaine's since we've no data). I view GI Joe as a MRE UNC so I suppose it's opposite number, BArbie, might be an UNC not a Yes, Clue is set for olden days, so it's an UNC, I don't know about Dr. McNinja, Pokemon is anothe rof those 'a little to surreal to to really be a Yes but Yes or UNC would be fair' and American Idol is of course, a Yes and disqualified.

Kylia Skydancer
MRE: Yes
MCS: UNC
GEN: Male
Buffyverse
The Sixth Sense
Captain Planet
Sherlock Holmes
The DC Universe


I list Wheodnverse/Buffy as an UNC but it could be a Yes in the ye of the Beholder, Sherlock Holmes is a no or at best an UNC, DC could also get a Yes or UNC, Captain Planet is a Yes as is sixth sense

Napoleon62
MRE: No
MCS: Yes
GEN: Female
Mario-land
Narnia
Wheel of Time
Portal-land
Winnie the Pooh-land

All of those are nothing near real world, and he said that he wans't, 100% solid

Talic
MRE: UNC
MCS: UNC
GEN: Male
The Land of General Mills
Booze Island
Sports Mascot Battle Royale!
KIKKOMAN The Original Teriyaki sauce!
Q is for Dr. Tran!


I think I did Talic already, most of these have decent options for UNC or are definite UNC, solid.

White Flame of Tar Valon
MRE: Yes
MCS: Yes
GEN: Male
American Idol
Les Miserables
Phantom of the Opera
Smallville
Chicago

MRE of yes, so Idol is good, I suppose Chicago is good if he means the musical, though the 1920's is pushing outside the Modern bit a bit. Smallville is a DC so could get an UN but it's very MRE-centered too, so yes is fair, Phanotm of the Opera is a No and so is Les Miserables.

Yunalesca
MRE: Yes
MCS: Yes
GEN: Male
The DC verse
Buffyverse
H20 just add water
The Office
Dollhouse


DC, Buffy, and Dollhouse can all get a Yes, though again I don't think 'Yes' is appropriate for DC as a whole, individual characters maybe. Office is a Yes, and the mermaid show is a Yes.

Okay, Summary
First off, about how I'm blatantly narrowing down options and exposing people, spare me, Darth Katie already warned everyone about that and the only person who replied prior was BlackAdder who's responses are 100% consistent anyway. I actually started writing this because I saw Hobo's and thought I nabbed a 0% true, but I remembered he swapped answers so that falls apart and it seemed silly to stop halfway done.

Okay, who comes up heavily setting-questionable? DK's a little tipsy but considering she was the one who warned everyone on this subject it's more likely she viewed her answers as consistent, so again, eye of the beholder. Fox is Willy-wonka or none of the above, and Artsapat's only got two possible. Nobody came up totally dry [shake's fist at DK] but we've definitely narrowed down potential fake RC's here, especially since the second half of the question kicks in as more relevant for individual claims as opposed to settings. If Amys and FT want to give settings, I'll add them, but they did answer both other sets of questions.