Active Users:619 Time:23/12/2024 12:55:55 AM
It's not the same experience aerocontrols Send a noteboard - 18/03/2024 01:48:00 PM

Every time the audiobook reader for The Expanse pronounces gimbal as 'jimbal', (and that word is used a lot, in every book) it draws me out of the story immediately. It bothered me in book one, and when the guy continued doing it in book two I had to look it up to make sure 'jimbal' wasn't an acceptable alternate pronunciation that we just don't use in aerospace. As best I can tell, it is not. Sometimes the audiobook readers for The Wheel of Time make mistakes, too, though I don't immediately recall any.

But the fact is that the written word is optimized to be read, and if you wanted to optimize for telling the story verbally, you would write the script differently. Half the ships in The Expanse have nicknames, and sometimes it wasn't immediately obvious to me that the ship that one character was calling 'The Canterbury' was the same ship that someone else was calling 'The Cant' and I think it IS much more obvious in text. In the audiobook, I was thinking we were suddenly talking about a new ship I'd never heard of, but I think if I had been reading the book, it would have been more obvious. Some stuff just doesn't work as well in audiobook form, I think.

Also, because it's an activity I do while doing other stuff (driving, mowing the yard, cooking, cleaning) sometimes my focus shifts to the other thing for a while and I have to back up the audio file and listen again. That's something that only happens with actual books when I'm reading when I should be sleeping.


View original post
Audiobooks - people are listening to the book. It is a passive action. They are not reading it. They are using their ears to listen to the book. Much like one can read a play or watch a play or listen to the play. The verb is different because the kind of action being performed is different.

Now whether it gives the same experience, I do not know.


Hollywood has the best moral compass, because it has compassion.
Reply to message
CONTROVERSY! - 07/03/2024 02:57:39 PM 339 Views
Oooh, those are fighting words! - 07/03/2024 10:00:30 PM 124 Views
That's bullshit! - 08/03/2024 04:02:38 AM 111 Views
I'll participate even though I personally would never troll... - 07/03/2024 10:40:35 PM 162 Views
Fo' shizz, old dude. - 08/03/2024 04:04:12 AM 121 Views
Audiobooks are great for re-reads - 07/03/2024 11:13:16 PM 119 Views
Possibly. - 08/03/2024 04:06:40 AM 133 Views
Re: Possibly. - 08/03/2024 04:55:51 AM 114 Views
That's not controversial, that's settled science. - 08/03/2024 01:42:16 AM 134 Views
There are people I like around here who insist otherwise. - 08/03/2024 03:59:41 AM 123 Views
why are you policing my sincerity ? - 08/03/2024 09:47:38 PM 114 Views
Can't wipe your @$$ with a page ripped out of your podcast - 08/03/2024 11:55:04 PM 116 Views
Nah. - 09/03/2024 12:18:25 AM 139 Views
That's fair. - 09/03/2024 03:38:16 AM 136 Views
As long as you admit your crimes, all is forgiven. - 09/03/2024 03:52:11 AM 120 Views
Well, my conclusive answer is "it depends" - 10/03/2024 10:29:10 AM 124 Views
Oh, I never meant it was the same as watching a movie of the book. - 10/03/2024 05:31:05 PM 116 Views
Reading a book requires text to read. It is an active action. - 18/03/2024 01:21:04 PM 122 Views
It's not the same experience - 18/03/2024 01:48:00 PM 107 Views
*NM* - 18/03/2024 02:09:57 PM 49 Views
Here's something that draws me out of the book sometimes - 15/04/2024 03:50:31 PM 96 Views
It definitely isn't. - 18/03/2024 02:11:19 PM 124 Views
Oh I agree. Some others in this post dont have a basic command of the English language. - 20/03/2024 12:29:28 PM 110 Views
*NM* - 20/03/2024 01:27:38 PM 52 Views
Dude. Language persists - 20/03/2024 01:52:17 PM 109 Views

Reply to Message