Active Users:317 Time:04/04/2025 02:15:25 AM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
Well that's how it was at first... but I don't think you can go back there now. Legolas Send a noteboard - 14/12/2023 07:57:52 PM

View original postThen the West Bank becoming a part of Jordan and Gaza becoming a part of Egypt would be the best outcome. If one think about the territory that is now Jordan, Israel and the West Bank, then the Palestinians are no different than the Jordanians except for the fact that the Palestinians are stateless post 1948. By incorporating the Palestinians into Jordan/Egypt, the chance for a terrorist org to come to power is lessened and there is a better chance for greater security and peace in the region.

Back in 1949, there wasn't much of a difference between Jordanians and Palestinians - they'd been administered separately during the Mandate and prior to that were in different provinces, but they weren't separate peoples. But that's several generations ago, by now they definitely are separate... neither the Palestinians nor Jordan would want that. Especially since, as someone mentioned elsewhere in this thread, Jordan has had bad experiences with the PLO trying to take over their country, so they won't be too keen to go back to the pre-1967 situation and take on a large number of additional Palestinians.

As for Egypt, they were a separate country from the Levant for most of their history even if there were also periods that they did control it, so definitely different nations. And modern day Egypt already struggles with discontent and Islamist resistance in Sinai as it is, besides all their more general problems, it's quite understandable they wouldn't want to add another restless province on the far side of Sinai, even if the Gazans wanted that.

Reply to message
The false narrative of the double standard damookster - 09/12/2023 02:33:25 PM 497 Views
ok *NM* Roland00 - 09/12/2023 07:27:01 PM 92 Views
Is this a good summary, NYT? Roland00 - 10/12/2023 01:20:47 AM 230 Views
It's as good as any. damookster - 10/12/2023 04:38:59 PM 182 Views
I noticed the OP was mostly opinion Roland00 - 10/12/2023 05:02:11 PM 199 Views
They dug their own graves Tom - 11/12/2023 12:24:16 AM 199 Views
There was an op-ed in the Washington Post claiming that antisemitism meets the Brandenburg standard. Ghavrel - 11/12/2023 01:01:39 AM 194 Views
Of course the pendulum will swing too far damookster - 11/12/2023 03:02:02 PM 187 Views
Re: They dug their own graves damookster - 11/12/2023 03:15:59 AM 182 Views
rhetorical question Mookie (it does not matter the answer) Roland00 - 11/12/2023 03:45:11 AM 187 Views
I have not damookster - 11/12/2023 02:49:55 PM 212 Views
Yeah that is why I asked Roland00 - 11/12/2023 04:24:40 PM 184 Views
There's a lot of double standards involved, aren't there? Legolas - 11/12/2023 07:02:06 PM 189 Views
We could go on and on with this damookster - 11/12/2023 08:58:28 PM 193 Views
that has NOT been my experience Roland00 - 11/12/2023 09:18:43 PM 195 Views
Yep, I know. Legolas - 12/12/2023 06:18:49 PM 205 Views
Re: Yep, I know. damookster - 12/12/2023 08:04:57 PM 181 Views
Re: Yep, I know. Legolas - 14/12/2023 01:33:53 PM 164 Views
Where do you get your stats ? AgentApple - 14/12/2023 07:09:02 AM 186 Views
the Hamas Ministry of Stats is likely an under-count Roland00 - 14/12/2023 12:57:46 PM 179 Views
Given the nature of Hamas, the numbers are likely an overcount The Shrike - 14/12/2023 01:16:00 PM 150 Views
whatever Roland00 - 14/12/2023 02:50:53 PM 165 Views
Given the choice between believing a Democracy and an Autocratic Terrorist Gov The Shrike - 14/12/2023 04:01:54 PM 169 Views
Chora I believe both are capable of lying Roland00 - 14/12/2023 04:16:14 PM 184 Views
To quote you, gurlfriend, "whatever". The Shrike - 14/12/2023 04:19:10 PM 172 Views
Obviously, anyone is capable of lying. damookster - 14/12/2023 04:30:29 PM 177 Views
You know that Roland is incapable of stating that the terrorist org Hamas is more likely to lie The Shrike - 14/12/2023 04:38:30 PM 164 Views
the names that Hamas was releasing in October Roland00 - 14/12/2023 04:49:06 PM 186 Views
What stats are you contesting, exactly? Legolas - 14/12/2023 02:12:18 PM 171 Views
Re: What stats are you contesting, exactly? AgentApple - 17/12/2023 02:34:34 PM 182 Views
Yeah, I'm still confused what you're trying to claim about the numbers Legolas - 17/12/2023 10:51:00 PM 170 Views
Out of curiosity, what do you think the best way forward is? Vodalus - 18/12/2023 03:52:34 AM 210 Views
I'm not sure your view of me on this is that accurate. Legolas - 20/12/2023 08:06:23 PM 170 Views
Because no one in the Arab world wants the "Palestinians" The Shrike - 14/12/2023 01:18:31 PM 179 Views
GDP per capita in Palestine is almost exactly equal to Egypt aerocontrols - 14/12/2023 05:36:55 PM 180 Views
There's always Antarctica Tom - 16/12/2023 03:22:01 AM 167 Views
From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free aerocontrols - 13/12/2023 03:01:21 PM 162 Views
The idea is free from foreign oppression - internal freedom is, indeed, another story. Legolas - 14/12/2023 02:33:21 PM 176 Views
Re: The idea is free from foreign oppression - internal freedom is, indeed, another story. aerocontrols - 14/12/2023 03:13:36 PM 169 Views
Re: The idea is free from foreign oppression - internal freedom is, indeed, another story. Legolas - 14/12/2023 03:39:55 PM 176 Views
From my perspective, The Shrike - 14/12/2023 04:09:31 PM 172 Views
Well that's how it was at first... but I don't think you can go back there now. Legolas - 14/12/2023 07:57:52 PM 182 Views
It means free of Jews AgentApple - 17/12/2023 02:41:09 PM 166 Views
Re: From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free damookster - 14/12/2023 03:32:17 PM 172 Views
Is the point to imply that 'pre-1948' meant no Israeli state at all? Legolas - 14/12/2023 03:56:59 PM 183 Views
Exactly damookster - 14/12/2023 04:28:01 PM 183 Views
Those 3 Presidents are Bureaucratic Scum. The Shrike - 14/12/2023 01:21:56 PM 187 Views
So Claudine Gay, Harvard Pres resigns Roland00 - 02/01/2024 05:55:09 PM 170 Views
Re: So Claudine Gay, Harvard Pres resigns damookster - 03/01/2024 04:38:14 PM 167 Views
Hey that’s not fair! Roland00 - 03/01/2024 10:51:43 PM 161 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes