Active Users:380 Time:18/11/2024 05:49:28 PM
For once I'm more critical than you... well, on one point, anyway. Legolas Send a noteboard - 03/12/2021 01:45:30 PM

View original post01:20 – Don’t tell me we’re dawdling over funeral services. This is just what I signed onto an epic fantasy series for – cleaning dishes, funerals, ladies-only coming of age ceremonies, bathing and dancing.

As you pointed out later, sadly way too much of this episode is taken up by that... one scene, I wouldn't have minded, but this was ridiculous. Episode 4 also deviated a ton from the book, but mostly in ways that made sense for exposition / background purposes. This is just a ton of plain wasting time - as if there wasn't enough plot left to cover in the book.
View original post05:47 – The geography in this setting is broken. The Two Rivers is a few days from Tar Valon, apparently, or else Moiraine and Lan have gone insanely far out of their way. Are they really needed to escort a gentled man?

There was a 'one month later' indication on screen, so that part isn't really the issue with the geography.
View original post08:04 – This view of Tar Valon, the Tower and Dragonmount is a lot more impressive than others I have previously seen. I still don’t like the design. This was built by the finest power-working humans could still recall after the Breaking, at the heights of the capabilities of the Third Age. Being a proportionately slim tower makes it look more like an impossible feat of engineering. This merely looks like a big building that took a lot of time or resources or mundane effort to construct. It also looks like it could have grown up in stages. The White Tower should be a singular work, like a wonder of the world.

You're overlooking the actual problem with the geography: they're on the wrong side of the river. Dragonmount is to the west of Tar Valon, so they should be passing it directly, not seeing it across the river. Based on that view, they're somehow approaching from the east.

Agreed on the WT itself, though TV as a whole does look nice.

Agreed also on many other points, but not going to comment point by point.


View original postLooking back at my first time-stamp, I had no idea what I was getting into. Something like 20% of the episode on three funeral/memorial/burial scenes that do NOTHING to advance the plot and tell us nothing about the Emond's Field main characters and at BEST, vaguely serviced Lan as a 'tragic hero with an unbearable burden of sorrow' type, which misses the mark wildly.

Yeah... and the Egwene/Perrin storyline inbetween is cringeworthy for different reasons, so pretty much a failure across the board here.

I mostly liked Loial and Liandrin is working fairly well so far, even if I'm also apprehensive about where they're planning to go with that... that's about it as far as positives from this episode go.



View original postAnecdotally, Jeff Bezos wanted Amazon to make the "next Game of Thrones." You know what Game of Thrones did to become wildly successful? Adhered as closely as possible within the limitations of adaptation to a different format and budgetary constraints plus the writers' limited comprehension of the themes, setting and characters allowed for the first three seasons. We did not have a good third to half of an episode devoted to the sad backstory of Desmond the Guard.

In fairness, the Song of Ice and Fire books are simply a lot closer to TV writing than the WoT ones - not coincidentally, considering Martin's professional background. It was always going to be necessary to deviate much further from the books in WoT to make the storyline shorter, more focused, more spectacular. But yeah, I defended episode 4 as largely good work despite a few questionable things, but episode 5 is hard to defend.
Reply to message
"Wheel of Time" Episode 5 - 03/12/2021 10:49:32 AM 873 Views
This entire episode was heinous. - 03/12/2021 01:30:35 PM 334 Views
I grow ever more thankful I didn't watch beyond the first episode. *NM* - 06/12/2021 02:36:26 AM 143 Views
But it's fun to watch and criticize! *NM* - 06/12/2021 03:13:06 AM 167 Views
I cannot understand any of you. - 07/12/2021 05:05:39 AM 238 Views
But you read these comments - 07/12/2021 10:30:11 PM 233 Views
To be fair, keeping up with RAFO ain't exactly time-consuming these days - 08/12/2021 01:51:05 AM 247 Views
Fair point *NM* - 08/12/2021 03:28:18 PM 122 Views
Not really, no. - 08/12/2021 04:37:11 AM 230 Views
Once again, you have taken a conversation down an unexpected and disturbing path - 08/12/2021 03:15:35 PM 260 Views
That's my M.O.! - 08/12/2021 03:31:45 PM 209 Views
Hmm... - 08/12/2021 03:28:02 PM 215 Views
Great, just encourage him *NM* - 08/12/2021 05:01:29 PM 149 Views
For once I'm more critical than you... well, on one point, anyway. - 03/12/2021 01:45:30 PM 253 Views
Wait wait wait - 03/12/2021 01:49:47 PM 267 Views
You're not wrong - 03/12/2021 02:10:19 PM 315 Views
WOTmaniacs, you are going to love this episode - 03/12/2021 05:26:35 PM 285 Views
Narg, stay. Narg smart. *NM* - 03/12/2021 08:31:00 PM 171 Views
Add Loial to the list of characters done wrong - 03/12/2021 09:04:09 PM 281 Views
The Seanchan - 03/12/2021 10:56:31 PM 244 Views
That was just my speculation - 04/12/2021 04:05:00 AM 298 Views
You know what annoyed me? - 03/12/2021 10:35:48 PM 277 Views
Ummm... - 03/12/2021 10:58:35 PM 234 Views
Nearly everything about the Whitecloaks is fatuous nonsense - 03/12/2021 11:16:56 PM 264 Views
In concept... - 03/12/2021 11:56:57 PM 255 Views
It's sort of doing this... - 04/12/2021 07:39:08 AM 299 Views
Re: Valda - 04/12/2021 05:04:18 PM 278 Views
Surely he's not dead? Just wounded, humiliated and out for revenge... - 04/12/2021 08:34:33 PM 221 Views
He should bleed out right? - 04/12/2021 08:48:14 PM 258 Views
For story reasons, I doubt it. - 04/12/2021 09:48:44 PM 266 Views
Yeah, you're sadly right. - 04/12/2021 12:40:06 PM 230 Views
That episode was as pointless as Crossroads of Twilight! - 06/12/2021 03:12:28 AM 228 Views
Re: "Wheel of Time" Episode 5 - 31/01/2022 09:44:49 AM 271 Views

Reply to Message