Active Users:833 Time:23/12/2024 02:44:57 AM
I can't see this being a good idea at all. Legolas Send a noteboard - 24/09/2020 09:27:43 PM

Even if it works for a year or two, which is already dubious enough, the Republicans would just retaliate further and possibly make things even worse.

In the mid to long term, the Democrats' real problem is not that there will almost certainly be a 6-3 conservative majority on the SC very soon. Their real problem is that, firstly, they need a liberal majority or at least a balanced court in order to preserve the constitutionally dubious SC decisions that legalized abortion, same-sex marriage and so on - when in fact those are things that should just have been settled by the legislative, like they were in almost all other countries. In decisions like Roe v Wade or Obergefell, 'conservative justices' weren't trying to push their own policy preferences in decisions, they just tried to block liberal justices from pushing theirs through far-fetched interpretations of the constitution. I don't see much reason for concern that they would try to invalidate, for instance, validly passed state or federal laws providing for reproductive rights.

And secondly, the Dems problem is that the Senate's bias in favour of small states has lately created a significant partisan advantage for Republicans, due to the increasingly urban-rural split between Dems and Reps which currently looks like it may become a long-term discrepancy. It's not that long ago that the Democrats held 60 seats in the Senate, but now they'd be unlikely to get beyond 52 or so even if this election would turn into a landslide in their favour.

Supposing that such a 6-3 conservative majority does in fact overturn Roe v Wade, we'd get to the point where every state would democratically decide about its own laws on reproductive rights. While that would be disastrous to millions of women in red states and I really wouldn't want that to happen, there's still something to be said for it because it would finally take the toxic abortion debate out of American federal politics. It's really not normal or healthy to what extent that one topic has dominated American national politics for decades.

Of course, Republicans should be careful what they wish for, because there are a number of potential negative consequences for them as well if Roe gets overturned - businesses or highly educated inhabitants abandoning red states for blue ones in large numbers, the Republican evangelical base having a lot less incentive to reliably vote Republican, the country becoming even more separated and even more at risk of eventually breaking apart. That last one is also a risk if this Senate discrepancy becomes too blatant or lasts too long.

Reply to message
Addition of Justices to the Supreme Court - 23/09/2020 05:22:49 PM 821 Views
The alternative is Dianne Feinstein living forever (she is 87) - 23/09/2020 07:53:59 PM 214 Views
Eh... - 23/09/2020 08:32:01 PM 247 Views
I have more confidence that Biden is movable. - 23/09/2020 10:01:35 PM 193 Views
Yep... - 23/09/2020 10:34:23 PM 216 Views
Why would you need this? - 23/09/2020 10:57:52 PM 196 Views
Neil Gorsuch wants to get rid of the EPA - 24/09/2020 12:05:54 AM 197 Views
Why do the Republicans? - 24/09/2020 01:26:43 AM 194 Views
Did you seriously write the GOP is indecent when they have a goal ? - 24/09/2020 02:24:10 PM 223 Views
Yes. I very seriously wrote that. One is a party whose leader just yesterday said... - 24/09/2020 03:23:06 PM 231 Views
I agree with you - 25/09/2020 03:41:22 PM 221 Views
Quotes, or you're a liar - 28/09/2020 12:40:27 PM 247 Views
The thing is, their behaviour now, though blatantly hypocritical, isn't particularly outrageous. - 24/09/2020 09:45:35 PM 220 Views
They're not going to have time for hearings, so it's pretty outrageous - 25/09/2020 02:44:23 AM 205 Views
Ok, but - 26/09/2020 03:14:57 PM 214 Views
Because October is not a full month - 26/09/2020 11:32:40 PM 198 Views
You're making an assumption that Herr McConnell won't have the Senate in session - 28/09/2020 04:18:23 PM 224 Views
I said that Greg - 28/09/2020 06:48:28 PM 213 Views
Ja wohl *NM* - 28/09/2020 09:06:30 PM 119 Views
Suddenly I am thinking of capes - 28/09/2020 10:21:13 PM 210 Views
The Sound of Music > The Ten Commandments. *NM* - 29/09/2020 12:34:48 PM 129 Views
Yes - 29/09/2020 01:56:11 PM 254 Views
Moses is a bad performer - 29/09/2020 08:03:53 PM 216 Views
heavy of tongue, huh? - 29/09/2020 09:47:08 PM 219 Views
Heavy tongues and assets. - 29/09/2020 10:26:42 PM 217 Views
So when the Dems loose.... - 23/09/2020 09:34:53 PM 219 Views
Tik for Tak - 23/09/2020 10:03:53 PM 215 Views
Not really.... - 23/09/2020 10:52:15 PM 208 Views
This is about human cognition - 23/09/2020 11:25:01 PM 199 Views
Yes, not really, but from the opposite direction - 24/09/2020 01:24:01 AM 214 Views
Why is this a standard only Democrats should adhere to? - 23/09/2020 10:37:07 PM 216 Views
When Garland was nominated - 23/09/2020 10:51:16 PM 228 Views
Nope... - 24/09/2020 01:25:50 AM 259 Views
I can't see this being a good idea at all. - 24/09/2020 09:27:43 PM 250 Views
I think you give too much credit... - 25/09/2020 03:07:32 AM 218 Views
There's a big difference between state legislation and federal legislation. - 25/09/2020 11:32:26 AM 206 Views
Not really. It'll depend... - 25/09/2020 05:01:12 PM 202 Views
Can't you reply to paragraphs correctly? Having to search for which part is yours is confusing. - 25/09/2020 07:55:03 PM 206 Views
Ah, my bad, sorry! - 25/09/2020 08:57:54 PM 194 Views
Re: the abortion debate - 25/09/2020 10:11:35 PM 198 Views
It can be and it is in plenty of countries, though... *NM* - 25/09/2020 11:11:28 PM 133 Views
Thanks. Been a while since I had one of these exchanges with so many paragraphs... - 25/09/2020 11:10:16 PM 218 Views
And another link... - 30/09/2020 07:07:19 PM 231 Views
Interesting interview on this topic. - 25/09/2020 12:35:11 PM 277 Views
Garbage article with elementary logic - 25/09/2020 06:36:23 PM 267 Views
If the Dems increase the # of justices, are they prepared..... - 29/09/2020 12:17:52 AM 212 Views
You are bad at Game Theory - 29/09/2020 01:35:33 AM 226 Views

Reply to Message