Active Users:631 Time:23/12/2024 01:32:21 AM
For what it's worth, Erica Tazel, who played Rachel Brooks on Justified and Emilia Clarke, are 5'2" Cannoli Send a noteboard - 22/06/2019 12:49:49 PM

Tazel carried it pretty well, too. I never thought she looked particularly small, although Timothy Olyphant, the star she often had to face off against, is only about average height himself. But I never thought Tazel looked silly or underage, even though her character was a deputy marshall, whose jobs mainly involve being bodyguards and dealing with convicts & fugitives. If there is a law enforcement agency where size should be a thing, it would probably be the Marshalls' Service.

I think Tazel could probably do a good job as Moiraine, but then making the Cairhienin black would be too weird. Elayne has very dark-skinned ancestors (Ishara was as dark-skinned as one of the Sea Folk [and she's Rand's ancestor too] ), but her father?

On the other hand, Emilia Clarke would be horrible as Moiraine. She's crap at acting regal, she looks childish and her build only makes that look worse. In "Solo," when she wore formal attire, she looked like a little girl playing dress-up (and the scene in Lando's closet didn't help). Imagine instead of one of the times she stared into the middle distance and uttered some nonsense about "breaking the wheel", she was deflecting the quite reasonable questions the protagonists often posed with "the wheel weaves as the wheel wills". NO.

Pike would nail every aspect of Moiraine's role far better than Clarke. And even though she's slightly too young as opposed to much too young (although Clarke IS in her 30s, she doesn't look it, much less look the part of an authority figure in middle age. She definitely does not look like she could get away with calling a 24 year old "child" ), she could pass for someone slightly older.

I think overall, the presense and demeanor are going to be more important than the height. It might be weird, since they are very unlikely to cast someone as tall as Rand or Lan is, but it's one thing to read about Moiraine dominating them despite being well over a foot shorter and something else entirely to convey in a photographic image. It was really really plausible that charisma vacuum Kit Harrington posed a threat to Emilia Clarke's authority without having to do anything in opposition to her, that people would be more inclined to see him as a leader and ignore her superior qualifications. There aren't many male actors I could see that being said about with regard to Pike.

Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Rosamund Pike is playing Moiraine. - 20/06/2019 11:16:24 PM 864 Views
More than a bit tall - 21/06/2019 03:22:57 AM 459 Views
5'2" per the WoT Companion. *NM* - 21/06/2019 11:33:40 AM 230 Views
For what it's worth, Erica Tazel, who played Rachel Brooks on Justified and Emilia Clarke, are 5'2" - 22/06/2019 12:49:49 PM 461 Views
Moiraine isn't actually "middle aged" though. She is all of 40-ish out of a 700-ish lifespan. - 24/06/2019 02:59:59 PM 449 Views
The text - 24/06/2019 03:25:58 PM 436 Views
Is her height a particularly important trait? *NM* - 21/06/2019 12:31:58 PM 225 Views
Only if it signifies that the show will be cast with no consideration for descriptions. *NM* - 21/06/2019 01:57:09 PM 236 Views
So you were furious when Hugh Jackman was cast as Wolverine? - 21/06/2019 06:33:16 PM 435 Views
No but I hated Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher - 21/06/2019 10:13:18 PM 449 Views
Who? - 21/06/2019 11:39:47 PM 429 Views
Re: Who? - 22/06/2019 12:23:45 PM 426 Views
Re: Cruise - 22/06/2019 06:55:28 PM 479 Views
Height is not always obvious on screen - 21/06/2019 07:44:00 PM 425 Views
I may be wrong, but I recall her physical height being referred to constantly in the books. - 21/06/2019 04:35:40 PM 512 Views
- 21/06/2019 07:45:33 PM 393 Views
I would say yes.... - 21/06/2019 04:48:12 PM 448 Views
Have you read New Spring? - 21/06/2019 06:34:39 PM 446 Views
But her thoughts are never vocalized on New Spring... - 21/06/2019 07:47:42 PM 463 Views
That seems like an odd argument. - 21/06/2019 09:13:51 PM 480 Views
Height's relative, and can be manipulated on screen, if needed... - 21/06/2019 09:46:20 PM 400 Views
I find it ineteresting that they are calling her role the lead role - 24/06/2019 02:41:40 PM 436 Views
Remove the PoV structure of the books, and she is the lead in Eye of the World. *NM* - 24/06/2019 05:08:44 PM 203 Views
I guess that depends on how you define lead - 25/06/2019 02:21:02 PM 426 Views
Moiraine was the Dragon Reborn?!? *NM* - 24/06/2019 05:36:37 PM 238 Views

Reply to Message