Active Users:1196 Time:19/12/2024 08:06:24 AM
More just a simple deduction. We've seen MCU FTL multiple times, and... Dunstan Send a noteboard - 26/03/2019 05:09:41 AM

View original post
View original post
View original post
View original post
Mar-Vell was collaborating with the Skrulls and that's where they were hiding out, so she left the Tesseract with them, because it was a really good hiding place. The Tesseract was used to reverse engineer the source, I'm pretty sure it was not in the engine Carol was test-piloting or the Kree would have taken it and left her behind. So clearly, Mar-Vell doesn't need the Tesseract to power the drive, so I think the Skrulls were able to leave without it.

1) The Tesseract was the source of the power for the vehicle Carol crashed. (In the same way that the Hydra weapons from <I>The First Avenger and the SHIELD weapons from The Avengers were powered by it. This is the only part that makes sense to me. Sort of makes sense, anyway, because...

2) The Tesseract was with the Skrulls because (a) Mar-Vell had another way to get from Earth's surface to the ship in orbit and she predicted that she would die that day and took it away from Project Pegasus to hide with the Skrulls, or (b) one of the Skrull refugees in the ship came down and stole it from Pegasus after Mar-Vell died. Must be (b), right?

3) You're right though, Mar-Vell doesn't need the Tesseract to power the drive. Sort of, anyway, because...

4) All the spacecraft in the film are faster-than-light, of course. Space travel on that scale doesn't make sense without faster-than-light travel. The Skrull refugees 'hid' on a 'standard' Kree ship that was fully stocked for years and carried them off across the cosmos as soon as Carol's story didn't need them to be on Earth anymore. They didn't need the Tesseract to do it. They just left. Because Talos is the only Skrull who knows how to drive or something?

5) So what was Mar-Vell developing? A 'lightspeed engine'? Kree and Skrulls already have that technology. (Maybe not MCU Skrulls?) What's so special about the one she built? That it requires an Infinity Stone for power? The Space Stone can teleport you instantly anywhere in the Universe - using it to power an engine is not exactly using it to its potential.

Bad writing.




It doesn't work like what they're making.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4AbuXmAArdk

The fact that they even NEED to make a form of FTL that simply speeds up the ship, means that the galaxy at large likely all use the jump system. Naturally, having access to a completely different form of FTL then what everyone else uses carries with it a tactical advantage... Hell, that in the form of the bifrost is basically the foundation upon witch Odin built his empire.

...Mind, what makes it just straight up stupid writing, is the fact that it isn't supposed to be an "FTL" drive. Rather, it is supposed to let their ship travel at the speed of light... Which takes "Sci-fi writers have no sense of scale" to downright absurd levels... They're called "light years" for a reason. It would take them freaking forever just to get to Alpha Centauri going at merely the speed of light.


Though to be fair, if they had no intention to use it as a primary means of getting from point A to B, but rather purely for tactical positioning... Well, in a setting where almost everyone else is bound to jump points, being able to setup a base of operations a light week or two away from the nearest one would be a really useful ability to have.

This message last edited by Dunstan on 26/03/2019 at 05:10:08 AM
Reply to message
So now that other people have seen Captain Marvel, am I wrong about a major plot hole? - 15/03/2019 02:37:48 AM 631 Views
The way I understood it... - 15/03/2019 07:42:20 AM 406 Views
I didn't understand the part with the Skrull family. - 22/03/2019 07:57:05 PM 378 Views
Re: I didn't understand the part with the Skrull family. - 24/03/2019 02:07:25 AM 366 Views
I think the writing was worse than that, even - 24/03/2019 04:52:52 AM 377 Views
Most MCU spaceships use a jump point FTL drive. They were trying to make one that could go anywhere. - 25/03/2019 05:43:11 PM 380 Views
Did they say that in the movie or is that speculation by you? - 25/03/2019 06:06:02 PM 377 Views
More just a simple deduction. We've seen MCU FTL multiple times, and... - 26/03/2019 05:09:41 AM 401 Views

Reply to Message