Active Users:930 Time:15/11/2024 08:17:31 AM
That third point is going a bit far. Legolas Send a noteboard - 12/01/2010 10:06:08 PM
3. Basically, although you probably won't admit it to yourself, the only reason for claiming AAE isn't a language is racism. You can't base such an argument on any characteristic of AAE itself, because not a single relevant fact supports that conclusion. No matter how much people try to dress it up, in the end it boils down to saying that the way white people speak is good, and the way black people speak is bad.

There are lots of dialects and sociolects in English - or in most other languages - that most non-linguists refuse to consider as separate languages. The fact that many of those language variations lack prestige, and are associated with certain groups, doesn't help of course, but that's not the main reason. The main reason is that people (including the actual speakers of AAE and the others) have political, ideological and practical reasons for viewing AAE and other dialects/sociolects as variations of English and not separate languages, because if they were as willing as linguists to see them as different languages, the variations would grow further apart and at some point in the future there might not be a common Standard English anymore. A situation somewhat along those lines exists with Flemish and "standard" Dutch, with the various kinds of Arabic, and I'm sure many other language situations.

So while MightyYT's way of phrasing it was somewhat offensive, I think you're exaggerating by accusing him of racism just because he doesn't think AAE is a separate language - I'm guessing it's part of a general attitude he takes towards all kinds of dialects and sociolects, without race playing any particular role.
Reply to message
So what EXACTLY is the problem with Reid's comments? - 12/01/2010 04:11:56 AM 880 Views
it wasn't just that he commented on the lack of "dialect" - 12/01/2010 04:16:27 AM 594 Views
Regardless of that, I don't see the ability to use dialect as a racist statement. - 12/01/2010 04:32:07 AM 544 Views
I agree - 12/01/2010 04:36:23 AM 563 Views
That's what I was thinking... - 12/01/2010 08:52:32 AM 571 Views
when was the last time you heard a white person speaking ebonics? - 12/01/2010 01:41:24 PM 554 Views
A week or so ago. - 12/01/2010 08:09:09 PM 490 Views
About a day for me. - 12/01/2010 10:33:40 PM 566 Views
Yeah, I'm back in Boston now, so... - 13/01/2010 03:33:38 AM 459 Views
Isn't that the definition of a wigger? A white person who speaks/acts like a black person? - 12/01/2010 09:49:34 PM 523 Views
So black person = N****r? Reid's looking better and better. *NM* - 12/01/2010 10:34:37 PM 250 Views
You know Tim isn't saying that. - 12/01/2010 10:43:43 PM 515 Views
Um, what? - 13/01/2010 06:55:21 AM 514 Views
And the fact that Wigger = White N****r isn't racist at all! *NM* - 12/01/2010 10:33:04 PM 284 Views
I wasn't using the term seriously 9_9 - 13/01/2010 04:26:20 AM 486 Views
The problem is he's a politician - 12/01/2010 04:35:51 AM 583 Views
because that would solve our problems. *NM* - 12/01/2010 04:37:18 AM 243 Views
You know, what IS a good term for black people these days? - 12/01/2010 04:36:33 AM 591 Views
technically... - 12/01/2010 04:39:51 AM 563 Views
i know, right? *NM* - 12/01/2010 06:11:33 AM 257 Views
I just use "black" - 12/01/2010 02:27:16 PM 490 Views
yah, that's what i typically do... - 12/01/2010 02:28:39 PM 564 Views
I agree. Say what you mean. - 12/01/2010 10:03:37 PM 534 Views
How many "black" people do you know that are truely black? - 13/01/2010 05:10:44 AM 509 Views
how many white people do you know are WHITE? *NM* - 13/01/2010 05:26:36 AM 231 Views
Why is it OK to discriminate on the grounds of language but not race? - 12/01/2010 08:23:21 AM 644 Views
Please tell me you were joking... *NM* - 12/01/2010 01:29:37 PM 221 Views
Not in the least. I thought you knew me better than that. - 12/01/2010 09:44:59 PM 485 Views
Ah! You were looking for an active rebuttal - 13/01/2010 01:48:20 PM 455 Views
It is okay to discriminate based on language... - 12/01/2010 01:40:18 PM 563 Views
Your AAE is a language the way that Pig Latin is a language. - 12/01/2010 06:38:35 PM 523 Views
I don't even know where to begin. - 12/01/2010 09:43:21 PM 594 Views
That third point is going a bit far. - 12/01/2010 10:06:08 PM 554 Views
You're right, I was conflating two separate points. - 12/01/2010 10:14:48 PM 496 Views
Well, it still only applies... - 12/01/2010 10:24:08 PM 639 Views
That it was a stupid thing to say? - 12/01/2010 09:49:05 AM 579 Views
this. *NM* - 12/01/2010 01:07:46 PM 252 Views
Who seriously uses the term "Negro dialect" anymore? - 13/01/2010 02:00:15 AM 484 Views
the subject is race. and party lines. - 13/01/2010 05:27:39 AM 476 Views
Powell, Rice and Steele. Just food for thought. *NM* - 13/01/2010 08:12:18 PM 307 Views

Reply to Message