Active Users:1070 Time:22/11/2024 09:59:20 AM
Implying FDR simultaneously disarmed AND incited war insults your intellect, not his Joel Send a noteboard - 04/07/2015 02:21:07 AM

It also ignores both the documented record and the body constitutionally charged with funding as well as raising a military (hint: Start with the mandate all revenue bills originate in the US House, NOT White House.) No one stupid enough to lay down arms yet invite war could have been elected governor of a major state, much less president; had he been that incompetent neither we nor, most likely, he would have survived the following four years of historys largest deadliest war. Further, the primary "evidence" used to call FDR a warmonger in the FIRST place is that he spent much of the '30s pushing for rearmament only to be "shot down" by congressional isolationists who insisted the SOLE means of deterring war was to be visibly unable to resist it.


View original postFDR was exactly the kind of arrogant jackass who would provoke a war despite being unready to fight. It's not a matter of opinion that he slashed military budgets to the bone, while at the same time making a series of hostile diplomatic actions that were toothless without armed force backing them up.

Correct, it is not a matter of opinion he slashed military budgets to the bone: It is a matter of falsehood and misrepresenting the basis of revenue bills, appropriations bills, military bills and ALL bills. Even if the budgets he submitted to the House (essentially by proxy, since neither he nor any president can technically author them) HAD denied ANY military funding, the House could and would have amended those budgets to supply all funding it deemed appropriate. So how many times DID the House INCREASE a pre-war FDR budgets military funding? And how many times did isolationists and fiscal hawks DECREASE that military funding?


View original postI've never understood people attempting to defend him (or anyone, for that matter) on the basis that the actions of which they are accused would be stupid. Hitler was far more brilliant a strategist than FDR or Churchill, and yet went ahead and invaded Poland well before the Wehrmacht was ready for a stand-up fight. If he could make mistakes like that, there is no reason why a spoiled rich politician whose only military experience was undermining his boss during WW1, and driving around battlefields as a tourist during the armistice, and being indulged by soldiers who let him fire the occasional artillery piece for kicks.

The fact that FDR was bound and determined to provoke a war and embrace it with only half-assed measures only makes him that much more reprehensible.


Now that IS a matter of opinion, and founded on a falsehood misstated as "fact," as the record shows. Isolationists cannot grandstand about "merchants of death" for a decade then blame disarmament on others--particularly not isolationists who decide military and ALL appropriations.

Honorbound and honored to be Bonded to Mahtaliel Sedai
Last First in wotmania Chat
Slightly better than chocolate.

Love still can't be coerced.
Please Don't Eat the Newbies!

LoL. Be well, RAFOlk.
Reply to message
racist mass murderer finally brings about the end of the US Civil War 150 years after the fact - 24/06/2015 11:41:08 PM 955 Views
And everyone needs to stop watching Gone with the Wind! *NM* - 25/06/2015 06:45:09 PM 272 Views
White supremacists use the cross and US flag at least as much: Should we ban those "racist" symbols? - 25/06/2015 08:09:30 PM 882 Views
The Democratic party has a worse history of racism than the army of the CSA. Let's ban that! - 25/06/2015 11:19:09 PM 720 Views
Not really, since the CSA was IN the Democratic Party then and is in the Republican Party NOW - 26/06/2015 11:16:30 PM 630 Views
I never accused FDR of preparing for war, just of trying to provoke one; which only makes it worse - 02/07/2015 10:20:37 PM 586 Views
Implying FDR simultaneously disarmed AND incited war insults your intellect, not his - 04/07/2015 02:21:07 AM 705 Views
The US flag was used to commit herindous war crimes against the Americans in the South - 25/06/2015 09:54:33 PM 650 Views
But we won, so we get the final say on what is good or bad. - 26/06/2015 02:52:41 PM 608 Views
And we get to fly our flags in protest of the war of northern aggression *NM* - 26/06/2015 03:27:59 PM 356 Views
All stand for the national anthem of the Confederate States - 30/06/2015 04:44:58 PM 773 Views

Reply to Message