This is a common misconception concerning the Protestants...
Dannymac Send a noteboard - 30/09/2009 02:42:23 PM
...among whom our dear Anglicans certainly number. The idea that the Reformers somehow broke with all tradition when they stepped their own way simply ignores their teachings wholesale.
Not a single first generation Protestant, from Martin Luther onwards, did so with the intention of leading the church. They saw human abuses of an old system and sought to reform it. Those within the system therefore drove them out, only to find that a great deal of others were more than willing to go with the new "heretics".
Even thus driven out, the second generation Protestants and onwards still had access to the complete tradition of the Church, both Eastern and Western, and that tradition informs us to this day. It is our history, as well, and we still learn from it. Even Rome eventually learned many similar lessons, with the Council of Trent and others like it eventually adopting the reforms that the early Protestants had been pushing for.
God may be unchanging, but Human Religion is not. With every generation, we learn more and more about the God we worship, and what we learn informs how we worship, how we organize. The early Hebrews were not Monothiests. The early Christians were predominantly Arian, even before Arius. Once upon a time, the primary marker of Ecclesiastical Authority was the age of the bones a Cathedral kept in its sepulcher, and early Protestants believed it was necessary to destroy all holy images in an attack on idolatry.
Human faith grows, and changes. Not all changes are good, which is why it is good to have folks protesting, every now and then. But simply because a tradition is older, does not make it better.
Not a single first generation Protestant, from Martin Luther onwards, did so with the intention of leading the church. They saw human abuses of an old system and sought to reform it. Those within the system therefore drove them out, only to find that a great deal of others were more than willing to go with the new "heretics".
Even thus driven out, the second generation Protestants and onwards still had access to the complete tradition of the Church, both Eastern and Western, and that tradition informs us to this day. It is our history, as well, and we still learn from it. Even Rome eventually learned many similar lessons, with the Council of Trent and others like it eventually adopting the reforms that the early Protestants had been pushing for.
God may be unchanging, but Human Religion is not. With every generation, we learn more and more about the God we worship, and what we learn informs how we worship, how we organize. The early Hebrews were not Monothiests. The early Christians were predominantly Arian, even before Arius. Once upon a time, the primary marker of Ecclesiastical Authority was the age of the bones a Cathedral kept in its sepulcher, and early Protestants believed it was necessary to destroy all holy images in an attack on idolatry.
Human faith grows, and changes. Not all changes are good, which is why it is good to have folks protesting, every now and then. But simply because a tradition is older, does not make it better.
Eschew Verbosity
How do different churches practice ecumenism?
26/09/2009 05:39:54 PM
- 773 Views
Do your own homework.
26/09/2009 05:49:35 PM
- 490 Views
In general, they don't.
26/09/2009 09:07:54 PM
- 559 Views
Re: In general, they don't.
26/09/2009 10:15:23 PM
- 516 Views
Benedict has never been a uniter, he has always been a strict interpretor of church doctrine.
27/09/2009 01:38:08 AM
- 551 Views
It's all translated...
27/09/2009 07:12:18 AM
- 434 Views
Sacraments, shmackraments. It's all too works-based for my taste.
27/09/2009 03:17:06 PM
- 423 Views
Benedict's Point
28/09/2009 07:52:39 PM
- 539 Views
It's a bad point.
29/09/2009 08:53:24 PM
- 390 Views
Yes, but . . .
29/09/2009 10:28:43 PM
- 675 Views
This is a common misconception concerning the Protestants...
30/09/2009 02:42:23 PM
- 410 Views
Because random nobodies on the internet are always the most accurate of sources
26/09/2009 08:32:37 PM
- 416 Views
I know in my grandfather's Episcopalian (sp?) church...
27/09/2009 03:30:31 AM
- 441 Views
You spelled it correctly, and yes, most Episcopalian churches offer communion to all. *NM*
28/09/2009 02:00:50 AM
- 171 Views
With AK-47s and hand grenades. *NM*
27/09/2009 03:41:48 AM
- 162 Views
I've got to join one of those denominations...
27/09/2009 03:43:30 PM
- 450 Views