I consider it revealing that the US MILITARY objected on the grounds of danger to human life, while the scientific communitys only concern was contaminating the lifeless lunar surface. That kind of inverts the popular view of scientists as noble idealists who alone stand between soullessly homocidal generals and murderous abuse of technology.
Well, first of all, the article said that the scientists "also" registered concerns about the dust thing, not that they "only" registered concerns about it. For all we know, they were concerned about the danger to human life as well. I'm not sure your interpretation is justified.
Second, how did you get your headline about Sagan advising them to nuke the moon? All the article says is that Sagan did some calculations for them as part of the planning. Sounds more likely that he was part of a team contracted to look at the feasibility, since he was "a young graduate student". The article says that his calculations were related to the release of dust and gas, not that he was the chief proponent (or even a proponent) of the project. So I'm not sure how you go from there to Sagan advising the military to nuke the moon. Advising them on some of the potential consequences of nuking the moon, it rather sounds like.
Warder to starry_nite
Chapterfish — Nate's Writing Blog
http://chapterfish.wordpress.com
Chapterfish — Nate's Writing Blog
http://chapterfish.wordpress.com
This message last edited by Nate on 03/12/2012 at 08:20:16 PM
Carl Sagan Advised US Defense Department to Win the Space Race by Nuking the Moon
02/12/2012 05:04:40 PM
- 733 Views
Mars can retain Oxygen just fine, and this isn't exactly new
03/12/2012 12:25:14 AM
- 391 Views
It does not seem to be doing a very good job of it; Mars' atmosphere is ~0.1% O2.
06/12/2012 12:16:16 AM
- 449 Views
There's a difference between retaining added and not having any
06/12/2012 01:44:56 AM
- 355 Views
Not practically.
07/12/2012 02:27:02 AM
- 970 Views
Yes, practically... I wouldn't mind you lecturing me on my own field if you got the stuff right
07/12/2012 04:19:29 AM
- 480 Views
Am I missing something?
03/12/2012 08:18:25 PM
- 505 Views
Perhaps Sagans subsequent suggestion we nuke Mars to make it habitable.
05/12/2012 11:00:08 PM
- 470 Views
Re: Journalists
05/12/2012 11:27:10 PM
- 490 Views
I am crediting professional writers with too much writing skill?
06/12/2012 12:24:49 AM
- 478 Views
I agree with Nate, lots of Journalists are very lazy and the science writers tend to be the worst
06/12/2012 01:55:16 AM
- 364 Views
I must have missed the part where Sagan advised them to nuke the moon to win.
04/12/2012 05:47:36 PM
- 409 Views