Active Users:400 Time:04/04/2025 10:54:51 AM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
I wasn't saying the UK is a normal federal country. Legolas Send a noteboard - 02/06/2012 10:17:08 PM
I was just saying that there were federal countries in either direction - the ones that started from independent entities joined together, or the ones that started from a centralized government and gradually granted more power to the states/regions.
In the UK, on the other hand, most of the country is under central control. Additionally, the system is asymmetrical – Northern Ireland has more devolved power than Scotland, and Scotland has more than Wales.

I've just had a look at how the Spanish system works, though, and I'll grant that it does look a lot more like federalism than ours does.

Spain does have asymmetry to some extent, actually, now that you mention that. Catalonia and the Basque Country, to take the most obvious examples, have more autonomy than the central Castilian-speaking regions like Castilia La Mancha or Castilia Y Leon. But yeah, the entire country is divided into regions, each of which has a separate parliament and all, even if some have more power than others. The English situation of being directly governed by a "federal" parliament that also has members of the other regions in it, is rather bizarre alright. But I dare say it'd be a political non-starter to talk about a separate English parliament...
This message last edited by Legolas on 02/06/2012 at 10:17:32 PM
Reply to message
For Our Nordmenn: What Happens to Federal Religious Holidays in the Absence of a State Church? Joel - 27/05/2012 01:33:20 PM 1150 Views
Nothing, they are federal holidays still because of strong unions, not religion Lews_TherinThelamon - 27/05/2012 06:58:52 PM 569 Views
Hypocrisy FTW, eh? Joel - 27/05/2012 11:04:38 PM 715 Views
No. Lews_TherinThelamon - 27/05/2012 11:16:11 PM 531 Views
Again, some people manifestly care; just not enough to relinquish a paid holiday. Joel - 28/05/2012 01:48:26 AM 567 Views
Nothing. jh - 27/05/2012 07:03:07 PM 528 Views
Replacing it with another, secular, holiday seems the responsible thing to do. Joel - 27/05/2012 11:15:11 PM 494 Views
People. Don't. Care. Lews_TherinThelamon - 27/05/2012 11:29:07 PM 551 Views
If people did not care, disestablishmentarianism (and its antithesis) would not exist. Joel - 28/05/2012 01:41:18 AM 690 Views
Most of them are stolen from heden traditions and have nothing to do with christianity. Milla - 27/05/2012 07:15:55 PM 736 Views
It's all about watching Kalle Anka and Karl-Bertil Jonsson Lews_TherinThelamon - 27/05/2012 07:40:45 PM 577 Views
YES! *NM* Milla - 27/05/2012 10:48:06 PM 491 Views
Since two resident history buffs recently excoriated me for that claim, I have no wish to revisit it Joel - 27/05/2012 11:27:13 PM 665 Views
Thanksgiving isn't a religious holiday. Tom - 27/05/2012 08:43:58 PM 603 Views
That is rather debatable. Joel - 28/05/2012 12:08:53 AM 674 Views
The Distinction Bored - 29/05/2012 07:41:47 PM 617 Views
Thanksgiving was a purely federal institution. FDR dictated the date it's celebrated Cannoli - 30/05/2012 03:22:09 AM 556 Views
That distinction would be an almost wholly Roman Catholic (or possibly Greek Orthodox) one. Joel - 01/06/2012 01:47:12 AM 516 Views
How do you come to four for Canada? DomA - 27/05/2012 11:29:57 PM 498 Views
Because I counted Thankgiving, and holidays for federal employees rather than just statutory ones. Joel - 28/05/2012 02:03:55 AM 656 Views
Re: Because I counted Thankgiving, and holidays for federal employees rather... DomA - 28/05/2012 04:31:14 AM 547 Views
Well, you know better than I, but I found the 1580s date interesting. Joel - 28/05/2012 04:08:31 PM 732 Views
Re: Well, you no better than I, but I found the 1580s date interesting. DomA - 29/05/2012 01:15:52 AM 568 Views
I was referring to the Wikipedia article I linked. Joel - 01/06/2012 03:34:11 AM 654 Views
Ireland has a tonne of religious public holidays yet no state religion. Stephen - 28/05/2012 12:48:55 AM 568 Views
I wondered how that would shake out for the rest of Europe, or at least Western Europe. Joel - 28/05/2012 02:29:16 AM 594 Views
This succession of two long weekends is rather nice, yes. Legolas - 28/05/2012 01:41:05 AM 512 Views
I think Grunnlovsdagen ate Ascension Day. Joel - 28/05/2012 02:57:27 AM 621 Views
It's funny how you use "federal" to mean "mandated by national government". Tim - 28/05/2012 03:49:17 PM 534 Views
I was thinking more "central" government, but OK. Joel - 28/05/2012 04:26:38 PM 558 Views
Re: I was thinking more "central" government, but OK. Tim - 28/05/2012 04:50:32 PM 520 Views
Re: I was thinking more "central" government, but OK. Joel - 01/06/2012 02:03:40 AM 726 Views
I think you've got the Scotland Act backwards. Tim - 01/06/2012 09:48:36 AM 652 Views
I did, though the practical effect is much the same. Joel - 01/06/2012 08:41:03 PM 622 Views
There's a lot of countries that call "devolution" federalism, though. Legolas - 01/06/2012 09:52:23 PM 627 Views
What about when most of the country is still under central control? Tim - 02/06/2012 10:25:47 AM 538 Views
I wasn't saying the UK is a normal federal country. Legolas - 02/06/2012 10:17:08 PM 580 Views
There is a Campaign for an English Parliament. Tim - 03/06/2012 10:12:21 AM 530 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes