Personally, I expected a little more nuance from you.
Gaps Send a noteboard - 15/01/2012 03:52:24 PM
Considering what I've seen at this site, the simple expression of an opinion that I personally feel no moral outrage that corpses of enemies of the US are pissed on by soldiers is hardly the worst post ever.
If it isn't rampant hyperbole, you're complete idiots.
It's not the most offensive thing I've ever read, here or there, but also the source: I would have expected a little more from you. It seems ill-considered.
You feel that your moral paradigm, militant western democracy, is greater than the Taliban's moral paradigm, militant Islamic theology. Well, that's fine: I actually agree with that. But there's a reason that human beings have come up with certain codes of conduct, for instance, the Geneva Convention, to codify the operations of war. Within that codification, to which our military subscribes, we recognize the inherent immorality of the desecration of dead human bodies. We say it's an immoral thing to do, whether it's done by our enemies or done by our own soliders, and we recognize that certain acts go above the finger pointing of "this side is worst than that side", and are inherently, universally "wrong". You're shrugging that off and saying that this immoral act is okay, because those other guys are so immoral, which unravels the whole ball of string. If the Taliban were pissing on the flag-draped bodies of dead marines, you'd very likely be upset. I find either circumstance incredibly disturbing and base, and "wrong".
(If you come up with something interesting in response, I might reply. Ad hom and I'm all set, as I'm reading Sex at Dawn and it's super engaging.)
I cannot even copy his manner because the manner of his prose was the manner of his thinking and that was a dazzling succession of gaps; and you cannot ape a gap because you are bound to fill it in somehow or other -- and blot it out in the process. -- Nabokov
Am I the only one who doesn't care if the Marines piss on the corpses of Taliban?
13/01/2012 03:28:08 PM
- 1724 Views
Probably not the only one.
13/01/2012 03:51:18 PM
- 1056 Views
Actually, IIRC, we were told the Afghanistan war was important because of the Talibans threat to us.
14/01/2012 11:18:28 PM
- 752 Views
Yes, that was part of it. Of course. AND we were going to help bring democracy.
15/01/2012 12:42:57 AM
- 722 Views
If we have time, sure.
15/01/2012 10:18:31 PM
- 865 Views
ooookay. *NM*
16/01/2012 12:12:06 AM
- 418 Views
?
16/01/2012 01:17:37 AM
- 783 Views
Re: ?
16/01/2012 12:22:39 PM
- 773 Views
I quite agree with Joel on this point (frightening as that admission may be).
16/01/2012 02:01:05 PM
- 768 Views
Doesn't matter.
16/01/2012 02:33:53 PM
- 768 Views
Your definition of "terrible thing" seems quite elastic.
16/01/2012 07:21:12 PM
- 693 Views
It undermines one of our stated goals, sure, but that particular goal was bunk from the outset.
17/01/2012 06:50:11 AM
- 856 Views
I am pissed at them
13/01/2012 06:00:56 PM
- 1061 Views
Congratulations: You are now where a LOT of Americans have been on a LOT of US policy over the years
14/01/2012 07:43:24 AM
- 859 Views
Congratulations you have again missed the point
14/01/2012 05:06:24 PM
- 775 Views
Not at all, you have just evidently decided it is relevant now that the President is a Democrat.
14/01/2012 11:04:17 PM
- 983 Views
Joel, you're full of shit in this particular case
16/01/2012 12:05:54 AM
- 1015 Views
Let's edit slightly: Joel, you're full of shit in this particular case
16/01/2012 12:57:22 AM
- 803 Views
He is applying a double standard, a practice I dislike intensely.
16/01/2012 01:15:05 AM
- 798 Views
no Joel you just can't see passed your politics
16/01/2012 02:15:51 AM
- 840 Views
I recall your disappointment in the soldiers then, but also your rejection of the view you took here
16/01/2012 02:27:36 AM
- 731 Views
I don't think that urinating on a dead body reflects well on anyone.
13/01/2012 07:47:20 PM
- 700 Views
Its indicitive of a breakdown in discipline and the erosion of the values of the corps.
13/01/2012 09:57:15 PM
- 918 Views
I thought this WAS the issue at hand. I haven't paid much attention to this story. *NM*
14/01/2012 12:00:53 AM
- 427 Views
I have a strong feeling that this was not the worst that's been done to those bodies
13/01/2012 10:43:34 PM
- 837 Views
Apparently the Taliban aren't too put out by it. They're still willing to negotiate and talk.
14/01/2012 01:32:59 AM
- 712 Views
Professional soldiers need to consider the impact of their actions on the cause
14/01/2012 08:25:30 AM
- 685 Views
Awful. Worst post ever. *NM*
14/01/2012 05:12:41 PM
- 572 Views
That's absurdly stupid of both of you. Expression of legitimate opinion hardly qualifies as "worst"
14/01/2012 08:46:30 PM
- 756 Views
it is our OPINION that this is the worst post ever.
14/01/2012 11:32:49 PM
- 751 Views
Wow. Remind me to point this out the next time Dragonsoul attacks you.
15/01/2012 02:52:47 AM
- 773 Views
im a little surprised that you are this offended by us calling your post the worst ever. *NM*
15/01/2012 03:52:51 AM
- 457 Views
Given the shit I've seen and the miserable way you've expressed yourself, I'm surprised.
15/01/2012 04:42:41 PM
- 704 Views
I agree worst post ever is one hell of a high bar
15/01/2012 03:52:42 AM
- 778 Views
Seriously, I once posted nude pics of a chat admins wife and THIS is the worst post ever? *NM*
15/01/2012 05:28:32 AM
- 404 Views
Personally, I expected a little more nuance from you.
15/01/2012 03:52:24 PM
- 1051 Views
Well, and I would have expected a lot more nuance from you. Your response was worthless.
15/01/2012 04:40:57 PM
- 927 Views
moral?
14/01/2012 09:53:01 PM
- 836 Views
I agree it was stupid to record it, and a breach of policy.
14/01/2012 11:05:49 PM
- 722 Views
im just baffled
14/01/2012 11:36:32 PM
- 741 Views
Well, in the future you can expect it.
15/01/2012 02:54:59 AM
- 728 Views
nobody said you had to cry about it....just acknowledge its a fucked up thing to do
15/01/2012 03:38:29 AM
- 699 Views
This shows that you are a bit of a sociopath *NM*
15/01/2012 08:08:39 AM
- 377 Views
You're still upset I called American girls prudes.
15/01/2012 04:43:31 PM
- 665 Views
I had forgotten you called American girls prudes
16/01/2012 10:22:50 AM
- 749 Views
You're right, I'm not really bothered.
16/01/2012 09:18:50 PM
- 1104 Views
There are all kinds of rationalizations why peeing on dead bodies isn't that bad in the grand
17/01/2012 10:32:45 PM
- 1082 Views
What is it about this post that is bringing the mediocre intellectuals out of the woodwork? *NM*
17/01/2012 03:18:29 AM
- 397 Views
as someone said on the radio recently...
16/01/2012 08:41:25 PM
- 757 Views
They aren't conditioned to murder, much less "in cold blood"
16/01/2012 09:15:54 PM
- 831 Views