I'd go with Benedict of Amber, his backstory makes more sense for the claim
Isaac Send a noteboard - 15/01/2010 08:34:57 PM
Considering how limited, unrealistic, and flat wrong the tactics or strategies employed by military geniuses in fiction tend to be, I'd say the only way to evaluate them would be 'whose backstory actually makes sense for the title of best general?', the alternative basically being to try to decide which author understood strategy best and which character they used as a proxy to discuss it, in which case RJ has a better claim than most, and I can't think of any actual generals who have written scifi fantasy, though I think I'd like to read them if they exist.
Such being the case, Benedict wins out, he's a millenia old near-demigod and spends tons of time watching battles then watching their alternate realities with minor changes, he's commanded forces big and small in places from the normal to the surreal, I'd say as major characters where descriptions are given, he probably deserves to have the title, after that Cauthon's claim is pretty solid, as opposed to Ender for instance, since Mat has the memories of a bunch of generals, thus vast experience. In the symbolic sense of things, benedict actually launched a succesful attack on the Gates of Hell in book 5 of amber, which is pretty impressive
Such being the case, Benedict wins out, he's a millenia old near-demigod and spends tons of time watching battles then watching their alternate realities with minor changes, he's commanded forces big and small in places from the normal to the surreal, I'd say as major characters where descriptions are given, he probably deserves to have the title, after that Cauthon's claim is pretty solid, as opposed to Ender for instance, since Mat has the memories of a bunch of generals, thus vast experience. In the symbolic sense of things, benedict actually launched a succesful attack on the Gates of Hell in book 5 of amber, which is pretty impressive
The intuitive mind is a sacred gift and the rational mind is a faithful servant. We have created a society that honors the servant and has forgotten the gift.
- Albert Einstein
King of Cairhien 20-7-2
Chancellor of the Landsraad, Archduke of Is'Mod
- Albert Einstein
King of Cairhien 20-7-2
Chancellor of the Landsraad, Archduke of Is'Mod
This message last edited by Isaac on 15/01/2010 at 08:36:56 PM
Sci-Fi / Fantasy 's greatest strategist / tacticians
12/01/2010 08:33:14 PM
- 1512 Views
Miles Vorkosigan *NM*
13/01/2010 05:43:12 PM
- 417 Views
OK. Those look like good books. I must remember to find them. *NM*
14/01/2010 07:41:53 AM
- 400 Views
I'd go with Benedict of Amber, his backstory makes more sense for the claim
15/01/2010 08:34:57 PM
- 803 Views
Aye, that's something I wonder.
15/01/2010 08:45:33 PM
- 735 Views
Like a scientist at a sci-fi movie, mostly they enjoy it, but blatant errors result in grumbling
16/01/2010 03:26:24 AM
- 717 Views
Napoleon from Napoleon And The Conquest Of The World
15/01/2010 08:47:35 PM
- 740 Views
...
15/01/2010 08:49:52 PM
- 737 Views
I have never it read it myself
15/01/2010 09:02:47 PM
- 724 Views
Oh.
15/01/2010 09:08:34 PM
- 811 Views
well I was thinking about reading it and I probably will when I have time
16/01/2010 06:38:39 PM
- 782 Views
He shouldn't have started a land war in Asia.
16/01/2010 07:07:10 PM
- 737 Views
Parmenion, the Lion of Macedon by David Gemmell...
16/01/2010 11:16:34 AM
- 827 Views
Rodrigo Belmonte, anyone?
19/01/2010 01:55:14 PM
- 851 Views