Although I am well-aware that fiction anthologies of all stripes are rarely discussed here, I thought perhaps it'd be interesting to hear opinions about what constitutes a good fiction anthology. As my sig line states, I've agreed to work with the Best American Fantasy anthology series (starting with vol. 4, tentative date being mid-2011, with more information forthcoming). Needless to say, how to structure an anthology (in this particular case, a reprint anthology) and make it appealing to a large group of readers has been on my mind recently.
So, for those of you who have read an anthology or who might if persuaded, what do you look for in an anthology (interconnecting stories, particular types of stories told, lots of commentaries by the editor(s), as little commentary from editor(s) and authors as possible, themes, etc.)?
When I read anthologies, I look for a few things.
1. Theme. Each piece within the anthology should work as its own piece, but should also work with the other pieces to form a whole. The stories should progress together.
That's going to be a challenge with a "Best of" reprint anthology. However, I do think it could be done with a lot of work, though. How much...perhaps I'll learn that from the Tootsie Pop owl
2. Pacing. There should be dynamics in the anthology. The works should vary in length and intensity, and should flow one to the next.
Agreed, although it'll again depend on the type of anthology being published.
3. Variety. There should be a diverse range of authors, writing styles, and types of story.
This one is the trickiest, as too much variety can kill any sense of thematic unity.
Yes, you will need to balance variety with unity, but I think it can be done. Seeing as you are doing a "best of" anthology, you could probably make "excellence" the theme.
The pacing itself will depend on the type of stories. With a horror anthology, I look for both the fast paced shock and gore, as well as the slow building terror. For Fantasy, I assume you'll want to look for short stories that read like windows into a world, quests, and maybe a small novella that covers an adventure party.
Maybe other types.
I was Phelix on wotmania, I will always be Phelix in the "real" world, and now I am Phelix on RAFO.
You will make all kinds of mistakes; but as long as you are generous and true and also fierce you cannot hurt the world or even seriously distress her.- Churchill
*MySmiley*
You will make all kinds of mistakes; but as long as you are generous and true and also fierce you cannot hurt the world or even seriously distress her.- Churchill
*MySmiley*
Anthologies
- 22/12/2009 11:12:37 PM
765 Views
Hey Lars...
- 22/12/2009 11:27:06 PM
523 Views
Thanks for the thoughts, Cat Boy
- 23/12/2009 12:54:48 AM
479 Views
- 23/12/2009 12:54:48 AM
479 Views
Welcome, my friend the tortured Squirel. 
- 23/12/2009 01:41:54 AM
449 Views
- 23/12/2009 01:41:54 AM
449 Views
Anthologies are like mix CDs. I don't really like them.
- 23/12/2009 03:39:12 AM
836 Views
I'm curious - do you read many short stories these days?
- 23/12/2009 08:32:14 AM
396 Views
Honestly, not many. But when I do, I prefer for them to be in a single-author collection.
- 23/12/2009 11:36:02 PM
615 Views
But some authors write such widely-ranging narratives that some anthologies are more unified
- 24/12/2009 02:17:58 AM
375 Views
Not to sound shallow, but honestly, I look for a known name ot two.
- 23/12/2009 04:15:45 AM
372 Views