It pretty much has to be since that isn't actually directly contradicted like the alternative.
Isaac Send a noteboard - 11/06/2014 02:25:38 AM
View original post
View original post
View original post
But he does callbacks so he could have done one there, witness all the canon-mess callbacks to him and Thomas building on the isle and having fraternal funtime in between Turncoat (when Harry gets the island) and Changes, during which time it is at least strongly implied he and Thomas have barely spoken and Thomas is being an inhuman asshole.
And Michael gave the reason for that in this book - the island is an oppressive presence that deters other people from going back. Harry notes in spite of that, Thomas and Murphy did actually visit him there a couple of times, so it's actually completely the opposite implication. View original postI was referring to their carpentry efforts discussed in Cold Days. In Cold Days, Harry mentions building the dock along with Thomas, on weekends when the two of them would come to the island and work on it, prior to when he was shot at the end of Changes. But Harry doesn't claim the island as his sanctum until the events of Turn Coat, and by that point Thomas has been captured and tortured by the naagloshii. He mentions in Changes that after they got Thomas back, he's only seen him for "two, maybe three minutes" since then. So at what point did they get together to build the dock and start repairs on other parts of the island?
View original postYou're right though. That doesn't make a lot of sense otherwise. Even the idea that they built the dock and so forth is a bit strange at that point. I mean, why would they, on the basis of a hunch that it would be important to Harry's future?
Yep, as oopses and retcons go its a small and harmless one as these go but it nags. My point really just being that author's do that a lot... take GRRM and aSoIaF where the whole 'Baratheons all have dark hair' ignores that the house has existed for 300 years whereas the Lannisters date back to antiquity and specifically to a story of their primogenitor stealing the sun to turn their hair gold. Making Stannis and Arryn's surprise that kids with a Lannister mother having blonde hair about as logical and likely as someone being surprised a descendant of hercules was muscular.
The intuitive mind is a sacred gift and the rational mind is a faithful servant. We have created a society that honors the servant and has forgotten the gift.
- Albert Einstein
King of Cairhien 20-7-2
Chancellor of the Landsraad, Archduke of Is'Mod
- Albert Einstein
King of Cairhien 20-7-2
Chancellor of the Landsraad, Archduke of Is'Mod
Skin Game discussion (spoilers)
- 30/05/2014 04:55:17 PM
1072 Views
Well, fancy meeting you here! I guess we're the only ones coming?
- 31/05/2014 02:16:06 AM
840 Views
Agree with most of that
- 06/06/2014 07:04:46 PM
696 Views
Maybe it refers to him attempting to bring the Fomor to the table?
- 08/06/2014 12:44:56 AM
958 Views
I enjoyed it but it seemed a bit weak
- 06/06/2014 04:09:24 AM
794 Views
Some responses
- 06/06/2014 06:57:50 PM
839 Views
Re: Some responses
- 06/06/2014 11:07:43 PM
823 Views
Re: Some responses
- 08/06/2014 12:26:51 AM
753 Views
Re: Some responses
- 10/06/2014 04:16:46 AM
795 Views
Maybe it was before the sanctum invocation? When he went to do it, he had returned several times.
- 10/06/2014 07:10:20 PM
711 Views
It pretty much has to be since that isn't actually directly contradicted like the alternative.
- 11/06/2014 02:25:38 AM
933 Views
You're not helping your point by mis-stating the Martin example.
- 11/06/2014 07:59:20 AM
737 Views
That's omniscient POV answer
- 11/06/2014 01:32:05 PM
810 Views
The Lyanna thing is fraught with theory-spoilers
- 15/06/2014 03:41:44 AM
719 Views
I'm quite familiar with theories of Jon's heritage, you do make some good points too
- 15/06/2014 06:04:19 AM
871 Views
A bunch of Jim Butcher tidbits from a recent signing (Isaac take note)
- 09/06/2014 02:50:22 PM
864 Views
Re: A bunch of Jim Butcher tidbits from a recent signing (Isaac take note)
- 10/06/2014 04:06:17 AM
986 Views