Active Users:621 Time:18/12/2024 10:07:27 PM
Then I guess the question becomes which one to recommend to you, eh? Legolas Send a noteboard - 02/07/2013 09:43:02 PM

View original postIt's a little amazing that it was never assigned reading in any of the endless number of literature courses I took in high school and college, and I haven't ever picked one of her books up on my own. My level of knowledge is so low that even though my ex-girlfriend loved them and had me watch one of the movie adaptations with her, I don't even remember which one it was. I might have been a little distracted.

Heh. They do all involve men and women falling in love and getting married in regency England, so if you're only half paying attention, they could indeed be easily confused for one another.
View original postSo not only do I not have a favourite Austen novel, I couldn't even tell you offhand what any of them are about. Whenever I think of Austen, I think of Jane Eyre, even though that's an entirely different author — but that's the one I have read, and I think of them together for some reason. When you mention what the obvious favourite adaptation is, I don't even know which one you mean. Maybe it was the one I saw, or maybe not; who can know these things?

Nah, I was talking about the Pride and Prejudice mini-series that everyone keeps raving about (not without reason - I own the DVDs and do love it myself), and which is also famous as Colin Firth's big breakthrough. You say you've seen a movie, so can't be that, then; I dare say you weren't so distracted that you couldn't tell the difference between a movie and a mini-series of six one hour episodes.

Comparing Jane Eyre to Austen... hm. Jane Eyre is more modern, one could argue, having been written a good three decades later (iirc), and has at least somewhat more variety in setting. Part of Austen's genius is simply having written six very different and very readable novels which are all set in that small subset of English Regency society, the country gentry / low nobility, and all have plots revolving primarily around female protagonists' search for a husband.

Pride and Prejudice is the most popular of her novels and probably also the best place to start, either that or Emma. If you don't like those, it's safe to say you won't like the rest either.

View original postRegarding the phase of adding monsters to Austen novels (I know about the zombies and the sea monsters), I think it's a lazy use of public domain property. It's attention-grabbing, sure, and it sounds like fun, but splicing new story into the old, existing text? Lame. If you want an Austen book with zombies, rewrite the whole thing so that it has zombies while coherently maintaining the existing style, themes, and characters, dammit.

Yeah. But then they'd have rather less readers, I expect.

I haven't read any of them myself, but I have to say there's one that sounds like it could be good. Vera Nazarian, an author who some people on this board think extremely highly of, has written such a version of Northanger Abbey, and you have to know that Northanger Abbey is largely a satire on gothic literature to begin with, so if you take the satire and then actually do add in monsters, that could be interesting, in the hands of a competent writer.


View original postIt is ridiculously hot in western Canada today.

I understand you're not alone in that. I have to say, I spent one summer in Canada once, albeit the other side (Montreal), and the heat certainly wasn't my favourite aspect of it.
Reply to message
/Survey: Jane Austen - 02/07/2013 08:51:08 PM 1295 Views
It is a truth universally acknowledged... - 02/07/2013 09:04:07 PM 747 Views
Re: It is a truth universally acknowledged... - 02/07/2013 10:05:14 PM 921 Views
Strangely enough, I'm that person who has never read Austen. - 02/07/2013 09:16:23 PM 740 Views
Then I guess the question becomes which one to recommend to you, eh? - 02/07/2013 09:43:02 PM 813 Views
I haven't read Austen, either. *NM* - 03/07/2013 03:32:49 PM 378 Views
I'm male, too. *NM* - 04/07/2013 11:57:14 AM 313 Views
Guess I'll answer myself as well. - 02/07/2013 10:31:08 PM 992 Views
I'm another of those non-Austen readers - 03/07/2013 05:12:53 PM 703 Views
I read them something like 17-20 years ago - 03/07/2013 07:09:20 PM 1157 Views

Reply to Message