Active Users:781 Time:23/12/2024 03:29:45 PM
Stonewielder thoughts Larry Send a noteboard - 08/10/2012 10:21:07 PM
When I first read Ian Cameron Esslemont's third Malazan novel, Stonewielder, in late 2010, I thought it was the strongest of his novels to date. Here is what I said in a guest piece for Locus Online on the "Best Heroic Fantasies of 2010":

Over the past five years, Canadian writer Ian Cameron Esslemont has changed from being known as “the other guy” involved in the creation of the Malazan setting that friend and co-creator Steven Erikson has established to becoming a respected writer of heroic fantasy in his own right. In his third novel, Stonewielder, Esslemont’s writing not only complements narrative elements that Erikson had established in his own series, but he expands upon central mysteries surrounding the setting and some of its cast of characters. One of those characters, Greymane, becomes a hero not because of what he has accomplished but rather for what he refused to do, despite the deep personal toll that this decision has taken on him over the past decade. Esslemont’s development of this character is handled well and the concluding narrative resembles strongly some of the more poignant moments in the Malazan novels. Stonewielder is Esslemont’s best novel to date and it is one of the strongest multi-volume heroic fantasies published in 2010.



Yet opinions can change over the course of two years and a re-read. Sometimes, appreciation can lessen, but other times, even a largely-enjoyed work can reveal new layers to the reader. During my recent re-read of Stonewielder, what I discovered was that Esslemont here provides a greater depth to the overarching story and to his characters than I had first noticed.

My earlier short commentary barely touches the surface of what I liked about Greymane's character. Although his scenes in Return of the Crimson Guard hinted at the potential of having a conflicted, mysterious character confront his past, here in Stonewielder this internal conflict is shown in a way that is subtler than what I typically expect from an epic fantasy, as there is no extended angst on display. Yet there are some interesting parallels to Greymane here. Esslemont devotes a lot of time developing characters introduced in his earlier novels, including the ex-Claw Kiska (first seen in Night of Knives), the former Crimson Guard recruit Kyle, and the ex-champion Ivanr. Each of these characters' conflicts were more interesting the second time around, perhaps due to knowing that in at least one case, there would be more in the subsequent Esslemont volume, Orb Sceptre Throne. Their arcs felt more important than any of Return of the Crimson Guard's subplots, perhaps due to a clear, more focused narrative here in Stonewielder.

The thematic treatment of contentious issues such as religious fervor and military occupation is deeper than what I've come to see as the norm for epic fantasy novels. The cult of the Blessed Lady, here revealed to be the main reason why the Malazan invasion of 30 years ago stalled, contains enough parallels to various forms of real-world religious fundamentalism for readers from divers cultures to draw their own conclusions. Yet there are few cartoonish adherents. Faith, even if it may be in a questionable form, is not denigrated but instead is shown to be a complex system of interactions between believers and the objects of veneration. Furthermore, this issue can be seen as a complement to similar questions of faith that appear in previous Malazan novels and may also be seen as a foreshadowing of what occurs near the end of The Crippled God.

Although not developed to quite the same depth, the effects of occupation on both the occupier and the occupied is shown here, through the "gone native" Malazan Sixth Army as much as the actions of the Lady's followers (and perhaps the Lady "herself";). Despite glimpses of something truly promising, there were some times where it felt that the scenes on the island of Fist could have been developed even further. This is not to say that it was poorly-developed but rather that I wish that even more space had been devoted to this subplot, as it would seem to dovetail nicely with the theme present in the overall series regarding the horrors and inglorious nature of warfare and violence.

Yet despite the missed opportunities to elaborate further upon issues that seem to be integral to both Erikson and Esslemont's novels, Stonewielder is the strongest novel to date written by Esslemont. Memorable scenes abound here and those who want to know more about the Malazan world, particularly Korel, will find a lot of new information (and new mysteries) to digest. For those like myself who need more than just "cool revelations" in order to enjoy a story, there is enough here that rewards those who choose to revisit the novel (and the other books in the overall series) after a year or two. Re-reading after having read the subsequent Malazan novels (The Crippled God, Orb Sceptre Throne, Forge of Darkness) led to a greater comprehension of what had transpired and it also provided a bit of light to that "fog of war" element that both Erikson and Esslemont utilize to keep readers guessing as to what the import might be to a particular statement of passage. Even when some of those mysteries are resolved elsewhere, there is still enough to generate an even greater appreciation for what the authors have created in their works.
Illusions fall like the husk of a fruit, one after another, and the fruit is experience. - Narrator, Sylvie

Je suis méchant.
Reply to message
Observations made while a friend and I read/re-read the Malazan books - 23/09/2012 07:16:19 PM 1389 Views
Interesting. - 23/09/2012 08:26:48 PM 893 Views
Re: Interesting. - 23/09/2012 09:03:48 PM 936 Views
I re-read Toll the Hounds this past weekend - 08/10/2012 10:11:56 PM 670 Views
Hm. I may need to reread it. - 08/10/2012 10:53:50 PM 629 Views
Re-reading the entire series would be best - 08/10/2012 10:57:22 PM 672 Views
You might find this interesting - 24/09/2012 07:26:50 PM 885 Views
I am familar with that - 24/09/2012 07:28:54 PM 717 Views
My commentary on Midnight Tides - 27/09/2012 06:06:41 PM 973 Views
I can see how that would work, yes... makes sense. *NM* - 27/09/2012 10:22:49 PM 306 Views
I'm discovering even more within The Bonehunters - 27/09/2012 11:50:01 PM 639 Views
And now, Esslemont's Night of Knives - 30/09/2012 05:23:31 AM 945 Views
The Bonehunters reflections - 01/10/2012 07:46:45 PM 962 Views
By the way, Erikson almost certainly has to be a Squirrelist - 03/10/2012 07:17:16 PM 676 Views
Reaper's Gale thoughts - 08/10/2012 10:03:17 PM 732 Views
Return of the Crimson Guard commentary - 08/10/2012 10:16:30 PM 714 Views
Stonewielder thoughts - 08/10/2012 10:21:07 PM 752 Views
Orb Sceptre Throne review - 27/11/2012 05:57:32 PM 733 Views

Reply to Message