*This post has further spoilers for both books*
For example, did you know that both books are liberally strewn with clues that tell us Kvothe is a Lackless? Meluan's sister, who ran away with an Edema Ruh, is Kvothe's mother. There are numerous clues pointing to the idea that Kvothe will release the name of the moon that was trapped in a box (the Lockless Bo, and/or that he will release Iax, who is likely imprisoned behind the four-plate door in the Archives.
There are indications that Denna's patron may be either one of the Chandrian or one of the Amyr, and that either way Bredon is a likely suspect. Denna is potentially weaving magic into her hair by use of Yllish knots. Also whenever Denna and Kvothe meet (which is only when they're not looking for each other), their first spoken sentence often contains exactly seven words. All of the random stories Kvothe has been hearing, the legends and fairy tales of his world, can be sifted and stitched together to form the bones of a real history in which all of the mythological characters, right down to Tehlu, play a part.
It is possible that the Chandrian left Kvothe alive because they knew he was a Lackless and has the ability to open the box. It is almost certain that they put him into some sort of trance-like stupor that caused him to act differently for the three years he was homeless in Tarbean, a stupor that was only released when Skarpi found him and used his name, similar to how Elodin brought him back from a stupor after he first called the wind.
The Adem and the Edema Ruh were likely once one people, before they split. It's possible that Devi the blood-money lender is seeking to open the four-plate door as well, and that she will be very dangerous. Her alar is described as an ocean at storm, which is one of the three things all wise men fear.
There are two main theories as to why present-Kvothe doesn't have his abilities. One theory is that he used his own alar, his strength of belief, to separate his mind (as he is good at doing), locking parts of himself away so that he can hide. The other theory, which I like, is that Kvothe has changed his Name, either on purpose to hide or accidentally when he opens the box and releases the name of the moon (which also causes the moon to return fully to the Fae and joins the two worlds, allowing the horrors of the Fae to bleed into the mortal world). If his Name, his true name, has been changed, he may have lost parts of himself, such as his fighting skills, his magic, his music, his legendary charm, his ability to convince people to do things, etc. Elodin has indicated that changing a true name is a very bad thing to do. If this is what happened, it's possible that Kvothe's true name is what's in the thrice-locked chest that he can't open.
All of this information and all of these clues were seamlessly and naturally woven into the book. It's a very impressive storytelling feat when you realize what the author is doing. Virtually every single chapter has at least some small clue stitched into it, some indication as to what the overall mystery is and how it will be resolved. Even the made-up foreign language words he comes up with contain clues. For example if you look at other examples of old words you can piece together the notion that Tehlu means First Lock, which works right into the Lockless notion.
Even Chronicler, his name is Devon Lochees, which is one of the outlier branches of the Lackless family, which split hundreds of years ago. Coincidence? There is also the Lockless family (lacking a lock), a Lack-key family (lacking a key), and a Lacklith family (lacking a monolith, ie. the greystones).
I can't wait to see how he pulls it all together.
In addition, I have to say that the writing itself felt much better in Wise Man's Fear. I had no problem with the writing in Name of the Wind, but in Wise Man's Fear it was noticeably better. The word choice, the descriptions, the cadence of the words, all very good, while telling an interesting story. There are parts of the book that become poetic and metered, but it doesn't feel like poetry because it's still in standard sentence and paragraph format.
For example, did you know that both books are liberally strewn with clues that tell us Kvothe is a Lackless? Meluan's sister, who ran away with an Edema Ruh, is Kvothe's mother. There are numerous clues pointing to the idea that Kvothe will release the name of the moon that was trapped in a box (the Lockless Bo, and/or that he will release Iax, who is likely imprisoned behind the four-plate door in the Archives.
There are indications that Denna's patron may be either one of the Chandrian or one of the Amyr, and that either way Bredon is a likely suspect. Denna is potentially weaving magic into her hair by use of Yllish knots. Also whenever Denna and Kvothe meet (which is only when they're not looking for each other), their first spoken sentence often contains exactly seven words. All of the random stories Kvothe has been hearing, the legends and fairy tales of his world, can be sifted and stitched together to form the bones of a real history in which all of the mythological characters, right down to Tehlu, play a part.
It is possible that the Chandrian left Kvothe alive because they knew he was a Lackless and has the ability to open the box. It is almost certain that they put him into some sort of trance-like stupor that caused him to act differently for the three years he was homeless in Tarbean, a stupor that was only released when Skarpi found him and used his name, similar to how Elodin brought him back from a stupor after he first called the wind.
The Adem and the Edema Ruh were likely once one people, before they split. It's possible that Devi the blood-money lender is seeking to open the four-plate door as well, and that she will be very dangerous. Her alar is described as an ocean at storm, which is one of the three things all wise men fear.
There are two main theories as to why present-Kvothe doesn't have his abilities. One theory is that he used his own alar, his strength of belief, to separate his mind (as he is good at doing), locking parts of himself away so that he can hide. The other theory, which I like, is that Kvothe has changed his Name, either on purpose to hide or accidentally when he opens the box and releases the name of the moon (which also causes the moon to return fully to the Fae and joins the two worlds, allowing the horrors of the Fae to bleed into the mortal world). If his Name, his true name, has been changed, he may have lost parts of himself, such as his fighting skills, his magic, his music, his legendary charm, his ability to convince people to do things, etc. Elodin has indicated that changing a true name is a very bad thing to do. If this is what happened, it's possible that Kvothe's true name is what's in the thrice-locked chest that he can't open.
All of this information and all of these clues were seamlessly and naturally woven into the book. It's a very impressive storytelling feat when you realize what the author is doing. Virtually every single chapter has at least some small clue stitched into it, some indication as to what the overall mystery is and how it will be resolved. Even the made-up foreign language words he comes up with contain clues. For example if you look at other examples of old words you can piece together the notion that Tehlu means First Lock, which works right into the Lockless notion.
Even Chronicler, his name is Devon Lochees, which is one of the outlier branches of the Lackless family, which split hundreds of years ago. Coincidence? There is also the Lockless family (lacking a lock), a Lack-key family (lacking a key), and a Lacklith family (lacking a monolith, ie. the greystones).
I can't wait to see how he pulls it all together.
In addition, I have to say that the writing itself felt much better in Wise Man's Fear. I had no problem with the writing in Name of the Wind, but in Wise Man's Fear it was noticeably better. The word choice, the descriptions, the cadence of the words, all very good, while telling an interesting story. There are parts of the book that become poetic and metered, but it doesn't feel like poetry because it's still in standard sentence and paragraph format.
you just blew my mind. I was starting to put a lot of those pieces together and may have figured it all out in a few weeks, but that was a very concise set of theories that all make sense.
I figured Denna was doing something magical with her hair and would hopefully help Kvothe with the mystery of the Yllish knot on the lockless box.
I totally picked up that Kvothe was Meluan's aunt, it was pretty plainly stated. Why Kvothe himself didn't figure it out - I figured his memories of his parents were somehow impaired by the Chandrian.
The Chandrian & the Amyr - I have suspected Denna of being a member, or at least applicant, to the Amyr for some time. Her knowledge of lore, her access to stories about the Chandrian (her song about Lanre was from an entire volume on the matter, if I recall. No one else had access to that kind of information). The "bloody-handed Amyr" - I was hoping to learn what the Maer of Alveron knew about them, but we never got that far. I still think we've seen at least two of them - I always suspected Threpe and the Maer, only because the connection between them didn't seem all that plausible. It's made clear that the Maer is swamped with pining nobles who will do his bidding, but he takes the time to correspond with Threpe?
I didn't get that the Ruh and the Adem were once the same. What clues were there as to that? I remember their origin story, but I saw nothing specific that pointed to the Ruh.
Kvothe changing his name makes the most sense, I think. right now his only motivation is to hide. Given the foreshadowing by Elodin towards the end of the book, it would seem that he probably did it not really understanding how damaging it could be.
Just finished The Wise Man's Fear by Patrick Rothfuss
14/06/2011 03:56:06 PM
- 1510 Views
I love the series, and was surprised to learn how much is happening behind the scenes so far.
14/06/2011 04:40:02 PM
- 1155 Views
wow.
14/06/2011 08:32:38 PM
- 1049 Views
Mmm.
14/06/2011 09:12:13 PM
- 1022 Views
While I love the frame story, I do want to see what happens now that Kvothe has "broken the world."
14/06/2011 11:54:59 PM
- 850 Views
Over Written
15/06/2011 09:33:35 AM
- 1047 Views
Re: Over Written
15/06/2011 03:41:27 PM
- 823 Views
Re: Gary Sueism
15/06/2011 03:49:24 PM
- 905 Views
I liked the book, but the events felt a bit... disconnected. Like a bunch of short stories
16/06/2011 03:37:47 PM
- 852 Views