It would be boring. aSoIaF adapts well because it's interesting and keeps you guessing at all turns. WoT just includes lots of pointless small plots that go nowhere that keep us guessing if they'll ever be finished or not. The overarching plot is somewhat predictable. When I was reading ToM I saw most of the major events coming a couple chapters away and from the discussions recently, WoT is very, very formulaic. It isn't unique enough to spend that type of money on.
GRRM developed a more in depth and more unique world than RJ did with WoT. I like WoT to read but I don't think it would do well enough as an adaptation to ever be worth it. You can see this just with the season distribution. One season to cover 3 books means each book is so boring that you can't just build up to the 1 climax. Few climaxes in WoT are enough to bring a viewer back for the next season let alone next episode.
If you're going to categorically dismiss a series that's sold millions of books and consistently reaches number one on the bestseller list, then I'm not sure you're worth discussing this with. WoT may not be your cup of tea, but to say that it is no ones is plainly not factual. The Wheel of Time has defined fantasy since its initial publishing. ASoIF can very much be seen as a reaction against Jordan's epic formula.
Besides, it's not as if aSoIF is that genius of a story either. Really it's just a bunch of scheming morons who can't get past their own differences to see the overarching threat looming over their heads. It's not much different than politics today.
What makes both series good is the quality of writing and character development. We fall in love with the characters and the scale of the story. That is what makes epic fantasy appealing. And it's the same thing that made star wars appealing too.
GRRM developed a more in depth and more unique world than RJ did with WoT. I like WoT to read but I don't think it would do well enough as an adaptation to ever be worth it. You can see this just with the season distribution. One season to cover 3 books means each book is so boring that you can't just build up to the 1 climax. Few climaxes in WoT are enough to bring a viewer back for the next season let alone next episode.
If you're going to categorically dismiss a series that's sold millions of books and consistently reaches number one on the bestseller list, then I'm not sure you're worth discussing this with. WoT may not be your cup of tea, but to say that it is no ones is plainly not factual. The Wheel of Time has defined fantasy since its initial publishing. ASoIF can very much be seen as a reaction against Jordan's epic formula.
Besides, it's not as if aSoIF is that genius of a story either. Really it's just a bunch of scheming morons who can't get past their own differences to see the overarching threat looming over their heads. It's not much different than politics today.
What makes both series good is the quality of writing and character development. We fall in love with the characters and the scale of the story. That is what makes epic fantasy appealing. And it's the same thing that made star wars appealing too.
You must unlearn what you have learned.
Wheel of Time Miniseries
- 18/04/2011 09:07:54 AM
1566 Views
Not a mini-series.
- 18/04/2011 11:43:32 PM
1042 Views
I would do it like this..
- 19/04/2011 05:15:31 AM
1079 Views
And while we're dreaming, I'd like a pony. How many 9 season shows do you know of? *NM*
- 19/04/2011 06:30:44 AM
418 Views
All the good ones.
- 19/04/2011 10:31:36 AM
963 Views
The Sopranos and Lost were hugely successful, and they were both six seasons long.
- 19/04/2011 06:13:06 PM
919 Views
Re: The Sopranos and Lost were hugely successful, and they were both six seasons long.
- 20/04/2011 05:49:21 PM
969 Views
This could still work with a 13 episode season
- 19/04/2011 07:04:06 AM
1213 Views
Based on GoT, I'm not too sure about that.
- 19/04/2011 01:43:36 PM
889 Views
Re: Based on GoT, I'm not too sure about that.
- 19/04/2011 05:02:34 PM
1054 Views
that's the best explanation of why it wouldn't work that I have ever seen
- 22/04/2011 04:06:03 PM
974 Views
One huge problem
- 20/04/2011 05:42:49 PM
1092 Views
Ok, man *NM*
- 20/04/2011 05:53:45 PM
592 Views
Hmm, I think American Gods might translate well onto screen. I hadn't heard of that yet
- 21/04/2011 06:31:21 PM
1077 Views
Is this post still on the books board? How odd. *NM*
- 21/04/2011 10:45:09 PM
464 Views
I left it here because it brings up several different book series. *NM*
- 16/05/2011 06:06:43 PM
427 Views