No, no, no, no, no. This is terrible, and terrible, Rebekah. I think it a very bad idea to have a small number of people in positions of some authority telling people how to do something. Even with your caveat, this sort of thing will make reviewing on RAFO a RAFO-boundaried event. Not as much in practice as in perception. We are not a magazine, you are not our editors looking for submissions.

However! You are right that people desire and want a little help. If your pointers section was open to commentary from other reveiwers, readers and the like - if it was a non-admin'd text, in that it was open for people to write in whether they're RAFOites, admins, random reviewers and the like, then I'd say that's a good idea. The fact is, a single post sounds like one voice, even if the single poster quotes many reviewers. Open it out to many voices and it won't be so bad.

<still shuddering at the horror>