Active Users:1126 Time:22/11/2024 10:25:53 PM
i agree as well, but i try to take the ending a little differently Apsalar Shadowdancer Send a noteboard - 30/11/2010 07:45:48 PM
I shared many of those criticisms, especially the convenient way the magical doorway or power the characters needed just so happened to materialize at the opportune moment.

Speaking of villains not living up to their potential, I found Flagg/Walter's death to be even more anticlimactic than the way the Crimson King was erased from the story, so to speak.

One criticism that I would add is the way King seemed to change fundamental character traits in midstream to suit the story, particularly with the start of book 5 (perhaps understandably, given what he had gone through in the interim and his desire to wrap things up). Before Wolves, it was clearly Eddie, not Jake, who had the Touch. I'm still not entirely clear on whether Farson and Flagg/Walter were the same person, and I'm not sure King was either.

With all that being said, the second and fourth books, and to a lesser degree the seventh, captivated me in a major way. Let's hope the big and small-screen adaptations don't butcher the books too much.


The Crimson King being killed by an eraser was unthinkably dumb. And I just didn't buy King's whole "I have no choice in all of this" when it came to how he resolved his plot arcs. You can absolutely do whatever you want to any of your characters at any given time. that's the whole point of BEING THE AUTHOR.

I also noted the shift in fundamental character traits and figured it was because he took so long to write the whole thing, but who knows.


The way I take it is that he is stuck in a "groundhog day" like scenario, where each time he goes through the events he gets another thing right, or wrong, as he marches toward the ultimate confrontation/last go round. We only saw one of those trips. Still it was highly unsatisfying as a reader to only get to see a middle point in Roland's journey. It also seems unusually cruel to trap the main hero in what seems like a never ender reliving of his failures.

I do agree with most of your complaints about the series. The only book I would consider rereading is Wizards and Glass. That was an amazing book, for me at least.
Reply to message
Just finished The Dark Tower series... spoilers - 19/11/2010 09:09:34 PM 729 Views
I generally agree. - 20/11/2010 02:04:58 AM 617 Views
Re: I generally agree. - 22/11/2010 07:09:03 PM 486 Views
i agree as well, but i try to take the ending a little differently - 30/11/2010 07:45:48 PM 714 Views
so how does it all end? - 01/12/2010 05:29:14 PM 464 Views
Re: so how does it all end? - 07/12/2010 09:17:24 PM 584 Views

Reply to Message