Active Users:1116 Time:23/11/2024 02:21:55 AM
Re: Thestrals & Hufflepuff - Edit 1

Before modification by Cockatiel of Doom at 22/09/2010 03:17:37 AM

Since this always comes up. It is not explained satisfactorily in the book why he can suddenly see them now, but couldn't at the end of the last book (or before that, as his mother died in front of him). From what I understand, however, it is not merely about having witnessed death, it is also about having processed that experience. To have understood it. I like this as an explanation.


I always assumed it was something along those lines. Yes, his parents died, but he was only a baby. He didn't really know what was going on. I guess seeing the vision in is head from the dementors doesn't really count either.

I also notice that Hufflepuff's philosophy of teaching is the one that prevailed in Hogwarts as a whole. I like this sneaking in of the influence of Hufflepuff. It happened in the last book as well, with Cedric as the best of his year.


Ooh, I hadn't noticed that. I like that. I do like the Hufflepuff people, but I have a tendency not to take them seriously because of their name. It's so... silly.

Return to message