Active Users:631 Time:02/04/2025 05:52:21 AM
Re: I'm fairly certain you guys have that totally wrong... Camilla Send a noteboard - 18/07/2010 05:51:36 PM
Disregard my initial explanation, there is no inconsistency!

In the Potters' case, they (the people, not their residence at Godric's Hollow) were the subjects of the charm. That means, no one in the world except for Pettigrew (and then Voldemort) could physically see them.

That is not true at all.

Firstly, look at what Flitwick says. Voldy could search their village all he wants, but he wouldn't find them. It the charm only concealed the two of them, then their house would be easily visible to him. How easy for the Death Eaters to simply blow it up when they were inside. The Fidelius Charm would then only be like a permanent invisibility cloak.

Second, look at Lily's letter to Sirius (which is found in DH). She says James was getting pissed off cooped in the house, and without the invisibility cloak, couldn't go out on excursions. If James himself was the secret, he could have gone and stood in front of Voldy, and no one would know! Plus, they have Bathilda Bagshot visiting them, Sirius and Petunia sending them gifts, etc. If they were now secrets, people would not be able to locate them at all!


All that holds for them being Secret as well. Bathilda Baghot could not visit them if their house was Secret, even if they were not. And Nobody could send them gifts if their house was Secret, as owls (or Postmen, for that matter) would not find it. I don't have the book handy. Are you sure all this happens after they have been subjected to the Secrecy Charm, rather than them merely being in (normal) hiding at this point?

Lastly, there's this from DH:

And along a new and darker street he moved, and now his destination was in sight at last, the Fidelius Charm broken, though they did not know it yet. . . .


That is fine either way.

This is Voldemort about to kill the Potters. Clearly, the Breaking of the Charm makes their house visible, not just them.


That is not a given from your quote.

In the case of Shell Cottage, and 12 Grimmauld Place, it was the location of the building that was the secret, not the inhabitants.

As I said, that's not true at all.


Fair enough and I see what you're getting at, but how would they survive? Stay cooped up in their house all the time? Sure, if DD was in on the secret, he could do groceries for them, but what if Voldemort captured and distilled the secret of the Potters' whereabouts from him?

You can't do that. Only the Secret Keeper can reveal the secret. Any others in on it can be tortured all they want, but it wouldn't help.


This is correct.

Plus, they were copped up anyway, as Lily's letter reveals.


Yes. But when was the letter written?
And either way, they would not be able to interact with the world.

And before you quote Gamp's Law, remember: the Death Eaters knew the general location of #12 Grimmauld Place but they couldn't simply fire curses at it and get it demolished!


Because the location was the secret. To fire at something, it has to be there in your awareness.

If it was the Potter's that were hidden and not their house, the Death Eaters could indeed have blasted it.


But would they have known what to blast?
*MySmiley*
structured procrastinator
Reply to message
Harry Potter Re-read: The Philosopher's Stone - Final section underway! (& next book plans) - 12/07/2010 08:27:51 AM 3103 Views
Chapters 1-3: Introducing Harry - 12/07/2010 08:28:49 AM 1677 Views
Characterisation *NM* - 12/07/2010 08:29:02 AM 935 Views
My thoughts, such as they are. - 12/07/2010 04:09:55 PM 1729 Views
Agree. She gave us enough to make it interesting. - 12/07/2010 06:45:46 PM 1693 Views
Re: My thoughts, such as they are. *spoilers* - 12/07/2010 07:43:49 PM 1668 Views
You hit the nail on the head. - 13/07/2010 12:20:19 AM 1627 Views
Re: You hit the nail on the head. - 13/07/2010 08:51:45 AM 1542 Views
Writing style *NM* - 12/07/2010 08:29:18 AM 922 Views
A couple of points. - 12/07/2010 04:10:20 PM 1559 Views
It is very clear it is a children's book at this time - 12/07/2010 07:18:14 PM 1750 Views
True. - 12/07/2010 07:36:49 PM 1674 Views
Re: It is very clear it is a children's book at this time - 12/07/2010 09:31:11 PM 1795 Views
Re: It is very clear it is a children's book at this time - 12/07/2010 09:51:23 PM 1498 Views
Vernon's slow descent into madness is great. - 13/07/2010 04:03:26 AM 1725 Views
Re: Vernon's slow descent into madness is great. - 13/07/2010 08:54:40 AM 1677 Views
Re: Vernon's slow descent into madness is great. - 13/07/2010 01:14:01 PM 1733 Views
Indeed. - 13/07/2010 01:15:23 PM 1503 Views
Early themes *NM* - 12/07/2010 08:29:37 AM 941 Views
Strong vs weak *spoilers* - 12/07/2010 07:23:45 PM 1519 Views
- 12/07/2010 07:43:27 PM 1554 Views
Re: - 12/07/2010 07:44:56 PM 1499 Views
Chapters 4-10: Making Friends at Hogwarts *NM* - 12/07/2010 08:29:58 AM 863 Views
Impressions: thoughts about the school, the teachers, the enemies and the friends. *NM* - 14/07/2010 08:29:38 AM 907 Views
I'd forgotten how annoying Hermione was - 14/07/2010 01:48:13 PM 1596 Views
Me too. - 14/07/2010 04:30:13 PM 1532 Views
Yep. I like seeing her transformation in this story though. - 14/07/2010 04:58:04 PM 1589 Views
Some thoughts before I run off to the library again - 14/07/2010 06:11:45 PM 1718 Views
Good points - 14/07/2010 08:45:56 PM 1659 Views
What about the magic? - 14/07/2010 08:58:51 AM 1593 Views
The magic wasnt really developed at this point - 14/07/2010 02:13:41 PM 1527 Views
Re: The magic wasnt really developed at this point - 14/07/2010 08:53:08 PM 1760 Views
There was one powerful protection - 15/07/2010 01:29:49 AM 1700 Views
I agree - 15/07/2010 04:51:05 AM 1657 Views
Re: I agree - 15/07/2010 05:44:41 AM 1531 Views
Re: There was one powerful protection - 15/07/2010 08:12:40 AM 1804 Views
I think - 14/07/2010 04:34:30 PM 1524 Views
Diagon Alley - Olivander's Foreshadowing - 14/07/2010 05:11:40 PM 1812 Views
Re: Diagon Alley - Olivander's Foreshadowing - 14/07/2010 08:51:06 PM 1510 Views
Agreed. - 14/07/2010 08:57:55 PM 1560 Views
I really need a remembrall. - 14/07/2010 08:57:10 PM 1670 Views
I felt bad for Neville. - 14/07/2010 09:03:49 PM 1677 Views
Indeed. - 14/07/2010 09:05:40 PM 1541 Views
But it doesn't tell you what you've forgotten! - 15/07/2010 02:51:47 AM 1805 Views
I know, right! - 15/07/2010 06:41:01 AM 1520 Views
Exactly. - 15/07/2010 03:22:18 PM 1428 Views
Re: But it doesn't tell you what you've forgotten! - 15/07/2010 08:15:55 AM 1529 Views
Ah, see - 15/07/2010 03:23:49 PM 1490 Views
Chapters 11-17: Harry the Hero *NM* - 12/07/2010 08:30:29 AM 885 Views
What'd you think of the ending? *NM* - 15/07/2010 05:21:38 PM 844 Views
Loved it. - 15/07/2010 05:56:06 PM 1579 Views
Two separate things: - 15/07/2010 07:14:08 PM 1574 Views
I hear you - 15/07/2010 08:22:05 PM 1591 Views
Re: Two separate things: - 15/07/2010 08:48:21 PM 1571 Views
I can clarify some stuff for you - 15/07/2010 09:14:07 PM 1599 Views
One of the most sublime, wonderful moments of any book - 15/07/2010 08:18:29 PM 1435 Views
Yes! - 15/07/2010 10:39:11 PM 1612 Views
Lovely - 15/07/2010 09:00:11 PM 1636 Views
Haha - 15/07/2010 09:16:16 PM 1735 Views
Re: Haha - 15/07/2010 09:24:06 PM 1614 Views
But I thought all girls were made of sugar and spice and everything nice? - 15/07/2010 09:26:53 PM 1524 Views
Oh, we are. - 15/07/2010 09:35:17 PM 1419 Views
Ah like vodka vs. wine coolers? *NM* - 15/07/2010 09:48:26 PM 834 Views
Gin - 15/07/2010 09:49:33 PM 1537 Views
I was 16. - 15/07/2010 10:49:33 PM 1426 Views
So was I - 15/07/2010 10:54:24 PM 1469 Views
Honestly, dumbledore is a bit of an ass... - 15/07/2010 10:48:32 PM 1432 Views
Heresy! - 15/07/2010 10:55:28 PM 1469 Views
As I indicated below, I had some issues. - 16/07/2010 03:05:05 AM 1730 Views
Re: As I indicated below, I had some issues. - 16/07/2010 11:14:56 AM 1607 Views
In fairness, it's Hogwarts itself that is all but impregnable. - 26/07/2010 03:55:02 PM 1551 Views
A funny thing I noticed - 15/07/2010 09:00:42 PM 1653 Views
- 15/07/2010 09:18:08 PM 1506 Views
Overall thoughts for the book - 12/07/2010 08:31:37 AM 1609 Views
Foreshadowing and setting up the future - 12/07/2010 08:32:10 AM 1517 Views
Harry's anger management issues? - 12/07/2010 07:14:58 PM 1579 Views
Heh. - 12/07/2010 07:40:40 PM 1620 Views
Nah, not deliberate. - 12/07/2010 09:14:20 PM 1680 Views
Re: Nah, not deliberate. - 12/07/2010 09:55:32 PM 1593 Views
Re: Nah, not deliberate. - 13/07/2010 03:02:59 PM 1533 Views
Re: Nah, not deliberate. - 13/07/2010 03:04:42 PM 1657 Views
I noticed a lot of this. - 12/07/2010 07:22:54 PM 1703 Views
Re: I noticed a lot of this. - 12/07/2010 07:39:25 PM 1642 Views
Re: I noticed a lot of this. - 12/07/2010 07:45:32 PM 1624 Views
~smug~ - 13/07/2010 02:09:15 PM 1596 Views
Indeed. - 13/07/2010 02:10:41 PM 1833 Views
This response implies the experience of being both?? - 13/07/2010 03:23:29 PM 1570 Views
On Ginny: - 12/07/2010 10:36:47 PM 1649 Views
So much (chapters 1-3) *spoilers* - 12/07/2010 07:35:57 PM 1812 Views
Hm. - 12/07/2010 07:38:05 PM 1630 Views
Re: Hm. - 12/07/2010 07:39:08 PM 1688 Views
Re: Hm. - 12/07/2010 07:39:53 PM 1490 Views
Re: Hm. - 12/07/2010 07:44:16 PM 1395 Views
Re: Hm. - 13/07/2010 04:41:12 AM 1507 Views
Re: Hm. - 13/07/2010 08:55:09 AM 1478 Views
I missed the school roof thing this time around too! Good catch there. *NM* - 12/07/2010 09:22:21 PM 857 Views
The thing that tipped me off - 12/07/2010 09:53:01 PM 1587 Views
Some stuff (chapters 4-11) - 14/07/2010 09:18:35 PM 1778 Views
Re: Some stuff (chapters 4-11) - 14/07/2010 10:30:23 PM 1598 Views
Re: Some stuff (chapters 4-11) - 14/07/2010 10:55:01 PM 1551 Views
Re: Some stuff (chapters 4-11) - 14/07/2010 11:05:59 PM 1573 Views
I can answer your consistency question! - 15/07/2010 02:35:42 AM 1709 Views
You are a clever cookie. - 15/07/2010 08:14:25 AM 1578 Views
Yes - 15/07/2010 03:30:36 PM 1430 Views
Ooh, yes. - 16/07/2010 12:19:13 AM 1403 Views
More stuff (chapters 12-17) - 15/07/2010 08:55:34 PM 1469 Views
Re: More stuff (chapters 12-17) - 15/07/2010 09:19:13 PM 1529 Views
Tiny tiny inconsistency (?) in Ch. 12 - 17/07/2010 04:23:15 PM 1662 Views
Re: Tiny tiny inconsistency (?) in Ch. 12 - 17/07/2010 04:28:04 PM 1572 Views
Re: Tiny tiny inconsistency (?) in Ch. 12 - 17/07/2010 07:12:39 PM 1823 Views
I like it. Thank you. - 20/07/2010 12:53:37 AM 1733 Views
What made this book (and the rest of the series) such a success? - 12/07/2010 08:33:00 AM 1682 Views
I have no idea *spoilers* - 12/07/2010 07:47:58 PM 1736 Views
I agree... - 12/07/2010 09:19:59 PM 1763 Views
It has tons of things in it that every kid dreams of doing - 14/07/2010 01:56:05 PM 1684 Views
Kid? - 14/07/2010 02:01:30 PM 1698 Views
so do I. I was just trying to act mature *NM* - 14/07/2010 02:08:01 PM 1040 Views
Not even just the super stuff Deadsy mentions. - 14/07/2010 04:38:46 PM 1822 Views
It's a simple, well-done little book. - 12/07/2010 07:46:48 PM 1670 Views
you don't read instructions, do you? - 12/07/2010 07:49:24 PM 1736 Views
Heh. - 12/07/2010 07:50:23 PM 1657 Views
Re: Heh. - 12/07/2010 07:51:40 PM 1669 Views
Awwww! - 12/07/2010 07:52:19 PM 1566 Views
- 12/07/2010 07:52:52 PM 1691 Views
Wha? - 12/07/2010 07:50:44 PM 1714 Views
Re: Wha? - 12/07/2010 07:52:21 PM 1702 Views
Pff. - 12/07/2010 07:54:54 PM 1685 Views
*NM* - 12/07/2010 07:56:03 PM 1043 Views
When did you pick up this book? - 12/07/2010 11:30:46 PM 1609 Views
I was 10. - 13/07/2010 04:13:44 AM 1759 Views
I was 16. - 13/07/2010 08:24:02 AM 1688 Views
1999 - 13/07/2010 09:03:03 AM 1676 Views
What do you mean by adult version? - 13/07/2010 02:15:40 PM 1798 Views
Re: What do you mean by adult version? - 13/07/2010 02:17:40 PM 1666 Views
Just before the first movie came out - 13/07/2010 02:17:42 PM 1835 Views
When Prisoner of Azkaban was a hardback. - 13/07/2010 02:23:57 PM 1682 Views
Just after Goblet of Fire was published. - 13/07/2010 11:50:38 PM 1747 Views
Just before Goblet of Fire came out. - 14/07/2010 04:04:21 AM 1711 Views
The first five were out, waited for HBP. - 14/07/2010 06:20:39 AM 1833 Views
You're making me want to talk about toadface - 14/07/2010 02:06:25 PM 1725 Views
Sorry! - 15/07/2010 06:36:11 AM 1759 Views
I held out quite awhile because I don't like "fads" - 14/07/2010 02:04:37 PM 1641 Views
Lol! - 14/07/2010 08:54:47 PM 1760 Views
I did the same thing. - 15/07/2010 06:39:16 AM 1754 Views
Re: I did the same thing. - 15/07/2010 10:01:04 AM 1932 Views
Re: I did the same thing. - 15/07/2010 05:44:28 PM 1811 Views
I would have, if I had known there was hype. I know I would have. - 15/07/2010 03:28:50 PM 1772 Views
- 15/07/2010 05:47:01 PM 1821 Views
I think I was first! - 23/07/2010 07:05:08 PM 1774 Views
Aged 13 or 14 - a while before the first movie (which was Christmas 2001). *NM* - 26/07/2010 04:13:55 PM 1018 Views
Jesus Christ. - 26/07/2010 05:04:46 PM 1781 Views
^That was me. *NM* - 26/07/2010 09:55:49 PM 1014 Views
I was going to ask if it was. *NM* - 26/07/2010 10:04:59 PM 1002 Views
Suggestions for the Re-read - 12/07/2010 08:33:25 AM 1711 Views
I like it so far - 13/07/2010 10:16:49 AM 1720 Views
I can try that for the next book. - 13/07/2010 11:21:01 PM 1694 Views
Can we get chapter discussions everyday? *NM* - 15/07/2010 06:40:30 PM 984 Views
Inconsistencies Re: the Potter's death... - 15/07/2010 05:16:45 AM 2033 Views
Because they were tricked? They considered Peter and Sirius to be brothers. - 15/07/2010 07:05:27 AM 1688 Views
That's nonsense.. - 16/07/2010 01:08:40 AM 1608 Views
Take it up with Rowling, since you don't believe me. *NM* - 16/07/2010 08:19:58 AM 933 Views
What's there to believe? - 18/07/2010 06:03:13 AM 1698 Views
Re: That's nonsense.. - 16/07/2010 09:37:59 AM 1827 Views
Also - 16/07/2010 11:17:51 AM 2042 Views
You are correct! There is no inconsistency - 17/07/2010 04:17:35 AM 1739 Views
Huh? - 18/07/2010 05:57:58 AM 1617 Views
But Camilla explained it! - 18/07/2010 09:27:55 AM 1942 Views
Correction - 18/07/2010 10:58:59 AM 1729 Views
I'm fairly certain you guys have that totally wrong... - 18/07/2010 05:42:18 PM 1633 Views
Re: I'm fairly certain you guys have that totally wrong... - 18/07/2010 05:51:36 PM 1647 Views
Re: I'm fairly certain you guys have that totally wrong... - 18/07/2010 06:17:04 PM 1947 Views
Re: I'm fairly certain you guys have that totally wrong... - 18/07/2010 06:28:27 PM 1639 Views
That bothers me too. - 18/07/2010 07:17:14 PM 1717 Views
Re: That bothers me too. - 18/07/2010 07:20:44 PM 1577 Views
Yet... - 18/07/2010 07:47:56 PM 1653 Views
Re: Yet... - 18/07/2010 08:02:31 PM 1698 Views
To quote Dumbledore... - 19/07/2010 05:57:23 AM 1587 Views
Again... - 18/07/2010 07:35:10 PM 1889 Views
Re: Again... - 18/07/2010 08:00:55 PM 1674 Views
Re: Again... - 19/07/2010 06:33:13 AM 1875 Views
Re: Again... - 20/07/2010 04:45:16 PM 1690 Views
Yet another load of bosh. - 21/07/2010 01:00:14 AM 1669 Views
Then let's leave it. - 21/07/2010 06:48:45 AM 1777 Views
Re: Then let's leave it. - 21/07/2010 04:19:35 PM 1692 Views
My two cents - 19/07/2010 06:11:30 AM 1750 Views
It was just the sort of things these two daredevils would do... - 14/09/2010 12:11:20 AM 2124 Views
Re: It was just the sort of things these two daredevils would do... - 14/09/2010 09:20:46 AM 1583 Views
You have to wonder if that's actually true. - 26/07/2010 04:23:31 PM 1655 Views
Re: You have to wonder if that's actually true. - 26/07/2010 05:06:43 PM 1761 Views
I don't know that I'd call it "see through Pettigrew"... - 26/07/2010 06:22:19 PM 1674 Views
^That was me, too. Oh, dear. - 26/07/2010 09:56:43 PM 1840 Views
Since Lily and James were unable to leave the house - 18/07/2010 07:14:21 PM 1635 Views
Re: Since Lily and James were unable to leave the house - 26/07/2010 05:07:48 PM 1957 Views
^ And this, too, was me. - 26/07/2010 09:58:07 PM 1683 Views
Re: ^ And this, too, was me. - 26/07/2010 10:05:41 PM 1612 Views
- 26/07/2010 10:07:36 PM 1498 Views

Reply to Message